Ultrathin-layer Chromatography Research Articles

Inkjet application, chromatography, and mass spectrometry of sugars on nanostructured thin films

Ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) potentially offers faster analysis, reduced solvent and sample volumes, and lower costs. One novel technique for producing UTLC plates has been glancing angle deposition (GLAD), a physical vapor deposition technique capable of aligning macropores to produce interesting separation properties. To date, however, GLAD-UTLC plates have been restricted to model dye systems, rather than realistic analytes. This study demonstrates the transfer of high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) sugar analysis methods to GLAD-UTLC plates using the office chromatography framework. A consumer inkjet printer was used to apply very sharp low volume (3-30nL) bands of water-soluble analytes (lactose, sucrose, and fructose). Analytic performance measurements extrapolated the limits of detection to be 3-5ng/zone, which was experimentally proven down to 60-70ng/band, depending on the sugar. This qualitative analysis of sugars in a commercially available chocolate sample is the first reported application of GLAD-UTLC to food samples. The potential utility of GLAD-UTLC is further exemplified by successful coupling with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for the first time to characterize underivatized sugars.

UTLC: An Advanced Technique in Planar Chromatography

As part of increasing research in the field of separation science, there have been many efforts to undertake planar chromatography with more efficient separation and better resolution in the shortest period of time, together with a specificity and a capability to identify more precisely an unknown compound present in a mixture. Ultra-thin layer chromatography (UTLC) is a modern technique which gives separation within 10–30 mm and development in just 1–6 min, with the consumption of less solvent. The stationary phase of UTLC is made up of a silica gel monolithic layer of 10 μm thickness having 3- to 4-nm mesopores and 1- to 2-μm macropores. Glancing angle deposition (GLAD)-UTLC is a modification of UTLC which gives separation within 15 mm distance and in less than 2 min. Anisotropic media of GLAD UTLC gives a unique migration direction effect. UTLC atmospheric pressure–matrix-assisted laser desorption ionizer–mass spectrometery (UTLC-AP-MALDI-MS) is a choice of technique for the identification of an unknown compound in a mixture or an impure form. ULTC-AP-MALDI-MS allows the fast changing of plates, produces more intact protonated molecules, less fragmentation and less entry of chromatographic material, and yielding less complicated spectra than the vacuum condition. Thus, UTLC is a useful technique for very rapidly giving the separation and identification of new components present in mixtures. This review provides a brief overview of UTLC, the stationary phases used for UTLC, and the detection options and applications of UTLC.

Ultrathin-layer chromatography nanostructures modified by atomic layer deposition

Stationary phase morphology and surface chemistry dictate the properties of ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) media and interactions with analytes in sample mixtures. In this paper, we combined two powerful thin film deposition techniques to create composite chromatography nanomaterials. Glancing angle deposition (GLAD) produces high surface area columnar microstructures with aligned macropores well-suited for UTLC. Atomic layer deposition (ALD) enables precise fabrication of conformal, nanometer-scale coatings that can tune surfaces of these UTLC films. We coated ∼5μm thick GLAD SiO2 UTLC media with <10nm thick ALD metal oxides (Al2O3, ZrO2, and ZnO) to decouple surface chemistry from the underlying GLAD scaffold microstructure. The effects of ALD coatings on GLAD UTLC media were investigated using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), gas adsorption porosimetry, and lipophilic dye separations. The results collectively show that the most significant changes occur over the first few nanometers of ALD coating. They further demonstrate independent control of film microstructure and surface characteristics. ALD coatings can enhance complex GLAD microstructures to engineer new composite nanomaterials potentially useful in analytical chromatography.

Aligned electrospun nanofibers for ultra-thin layer chromatography

The fabrication and implementation of aligned electrospun polyacrylonitrile (PAN) nanofibers as a stationary phase for ultra-thin layer chromatography (UTLC) is described. The aligned electrospun UTLC plates (AE-UTLC) were characterized to give an optimized electrospun mat consisting of high nanofiber alignment and a mat thickness of ∼25μm. The AE-UTLC devices were used to separate a mixture of β-blockers and steroidal compounds to illustrate the properties of AE-UTLC. The AE-UTLC plates provided shorter analysis time (∼2–2.5 times faster) with improved reproducibility (as high as 2 times) as well as an improvement in efficiency (up to100 times greater) relative to non-aligned electrospun-UTLC (E-UTLC) devices.

Polarity-adjustable reversed phase ultrathin-layer chromatography

Reversed phase thin layer chromatography (TLC) or high performance thin layer chromatography (HPTLC) plates modified with C18, C8 or C2 to provide the silica-gel stationary phase with different polarities are available on the market, however, reversed phase plates with tunable polarity have not been reported. Given the limited variety of reversed phase plates, mobile phase composition optimization is necessary to obtain better separation of analytes with similar characteristics, which is often a time consuming step. We present polarity-adjustable reversed phase ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) plates, which simplifies the mobile phase screening process and greatly expands the selection of reversed phase plates. The plates were fabricated on glass substrates with SiO2 nanopillars deposited using the glancing angle deposition (GLAD) technique. SiO2 nanopillars were functionalized with octadecyltrichlorosilane to generate a super hydrophobic stationary phase. Unlike commercial silica-gel based stationary phases, the isolated nanopillar architecture presented here exposes a high surface area to post-fabrication surface treatments. In our work, an O2 plasma treatment at different powers, pressures and exposure times was used to shorten the silane carbon chain and introduce COOH groups to the surface, producing plates with finely tunable polarities. Separation of a model dye mixture of Sudan blue and Sudan IV confirmed the tuning of surface polarities by measurement of retention behavior changes. The dye elution order reversed as a result of the change in surface polarity. When the same plasma treatment process was tested on commercial reversed phase plates, separation behavior did not change because the disordered and tortuous silica gel restricts the accessible surface area. Plasma treatment of GLAD structures with highly accessible surfaces improved control over interfacial properties, producing better reverse phase separations.

Time resolved chromatograms in ultra-thin layer chromatography

Ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) is a recently developed analytical method intended for compact, rapid separations of nanolitre analyte volumes. Optimizing this method's performance requires new measurement techniques compatible with the millimetre length scales and rapid separation dynamics observed in UTLC. We have designed, implemented and characterized a measurement system which records UTLC separations in full color with 32μm spatial resolution and 33ms temporal resolution. Our code analyzes multiple tracks per plate, filters analyte spots by color, and automatically generates time-resolved figures of merit. The instrument presented here captures a wealth of information from a UTLC separation, and should provide insight into UTLC physics and improved analytical performance.

On-Chip Ultra-Thin Layer Chromatography and Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

We demonstrate that silver nanorod (AgNR) array substrates can be used for on-chip separation and detection of chemical mixtures by combining ultra-thin layer chromatography (UTLC) and surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS). The UTLC-SERS plate consists of an AgNR array fabricated by oblique angle deposition. The capability of the AgNR substrates to separate the different compounds in a mixture was explored using a mixture of four dyes and a mixture of melamine and Rhodamine 6G at varied concentrations with different mobile phase solvents. After UTLC separation, spatially-resolved SERS spectra were collected along the mobile phase development direction and the intensities of specific SERS peaks from each component were used to generate chromatograms. The AgNR substrates demonstrate the potential for separating the test dyes with plate heights as low as 9.6 μm. The limits of detection are between 10(-5)-10(-6) M. Furthermore, we show that the coupling of UTLC with SERS improves the SERS detection specificity, as small amounts of target analytes can be separated from the interfering background components.

Morphological modification of nanostructured ultrathin-layer chromatography stationary phases

Ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) provides the high sensitivities and rapid separations over short distances desirable in many analytical applications. The dependence of these performance benefits on UTLC layer microstructure motivates continued stationary phase engineering efforts. A new method of modifying the elution behaviours of nanostructured thin film UTLC stationary phases is investigated in this report. Macroporous normal phase silica thin films ∼5 μm thick were fabricated using glancing angle deposition (GLAD). Reactive ion etching (RIE) and a subsequent annealing treatment modified stationary phase morphology to tune migration velocity, analyte retention, and overall separation performance. Combining this technique with a RIE shadow mask enabled fabrication of adjacent concentration and separation zones with markedly different elution properties. Although produced using an entirely new approach, GLAD UTLC concentration zone media behaved in a manner consistent with traditional thin-layer chromatography (TLC) and high-performance TLC (HPTLC) concentration zone plates. In particular, these new media focused large volume, low concentration dye mixture spots into narrow bands to achieve high-quality separations. The described approach to modifying the morphology and resultant elution behaviours of nanostructured stationary phases expands the capabilities of the GLAD UTLC technique.

Protein UTLC-MALDI–MS using thin films of submicrometer silica particles

Slides for ultra thin-layer chromatography (UTLC) were made by coating nonporous silica particles, chemically modified with polyacrylamide, as 15 μm films on glass or silicon. Three proteins, myoglobin, cytochrome c and lysozyme, are nearly baseline resolved by the mechanism of hydrophilic interaction chromatography. A plate height as low as 3 μm, with 3900 plates, is observed in 14 mm. Varying silica particle diameter among 900, 700 and 350 nm showed that decreasing particle diameter slightly improves resolution but slows the separation. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)-MS of the proteins after separation is demonstrated by wicking sufficient sinapinic acid into the separation medium.

Analyte migration in anisotropic nanostructured ultrathin-layer chromatography media

We investigate the performance of highly anisotropic nanostructured thin film ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) media with porosity and architecture engineered using the glancing-angle deposition (GLAD) process. Our anisotropic structures resemble nanoblades, producing channel-like features that partially decouple analyte migration from development direction, offering new separation behaviours. Here we study GLAD-UTLC plate performance in terms of migration distance, plate number, retention factor and a figure of merit specific to GLAD-UTLC, track deviation angle. Migration distances increase with porosity by a factor of two for all feature orientations (up to a maximum of 22 mm) over the range of porosities considered in this study. Plate numbers approaching 1100 are observed for GLAD-UTLC plates when the nanoblade features are aligned with the development direction. We present a theoretical model describing mobile phase flow in anisotropic GLAD-UTLC media, and find good agreement with experimental results. Our plates provide channel features that reduce transverse spot broadening while providing the wide pores required for rapid migration and high separation performance. These improvements may enable a greater number of parallel separations on miniaturized GLAD-UTLC plate formats. Their small sizes should also make them compatible with the Office Chromatography concept in which office peripherals (inkjet printers and flatbed scanners) replace conventional TLC instruments. Equipped with a better understanding of the unique GLAD-UTLC elution behaviours, we expect to further improve performance in the future.

Engineered Anisotropic Microstructures for Ultrathin-Layer Chromatography

The strong dependence of separation behavior on ultrathin-layer chromatography (UTLC) stationary phase microstructure motivates continued UTLC plate design optimization efforts. We fabricated 4.6-5.3 mum thick normal phase silica UTLC stationary phases with several types of in-plane macropore anisotropies using the glancing angle deposition (GLAD) approach to engineering nanostructured thin films. The separation behaviors of two new media, isotropic vertical posts and anisotropic bladelike films, were compared to that of anisotropic chevron media. Channel-like structures within the anisotropic media introduced preferential mobile phase flow directions that could be exploited to give separation tracks diagonal to the development direction. Extraction of chromatograms from these angled tracks required the development of a new analytical approach that involved a commercial flatbed film scanner and custom numerical image analysis software. GLAD stationary phase performance was quantified using the Dimethyl Yellow dye separated from a lipophilic dye mixture over migration distances less than approximately 10 mm. The limits of detection were 10 +/- 4 ng for the vertical posts and 11 +/- 3 ng for the bladelike media. We obtained theoretical plate heights that varied with film microstructure between 12 and 28 mum. Unoptimized separation performance was comparable to that of other planar chromatography media. Macropore anisotropies engineered by GLAD may expand the capabilities of future UTLC stationary phases.

Electrospun glassy carbon ultra-thin layer chromatography devices

The development and application of electrospun glassy carbon nanofibers for ultra-thin layer chromatography (UTLC) are described. The carbon nanofiber stationary phase is created through the electrospinning and pyrolysis of SU-8 2100 photoresist. This results in glassy carbon nanofibers with diameters of ∼200–350 nm that form a mat structure with a thickness of ∼15 μm. The chromatographic properties of UTLC devices produced from pyrolyzed SU-8 heated to temperatures of 600, 800, and 1000 °C are described. Raman spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) are used to characterize the physical and molecular structure of the nanofibers at each temperature. A set of six laser dyes was examined to demonstrate the applicability of the devices. Analyses of the retention properties of the individual dyes as well as the separation of mixtures of three dyes were performed. A mixture of three FITC-labeled essential amino acids: lysine, threonine and phenylalanine, was examined and fully resolved on the carbon UTLC devices as well. The electrospun glassy carbon UTLC plates show tunable retention, have plate number, N, values above 10,000, and show physical and chemical robustness for a range of mobile phases.

Ultrathin-layer chromatography spotting and detection on the sub-millimeter scale

Ultrathin-layer chromatography spotting and detection on the sub-millimeter scale

Technique for Ultrathin Layer Chromatography Using an Electrospun, Nanofibrous Stationary Phase

A technique for creating devices for ultrathin layer chromatography (UTLC) using an electrospinning method is described. The devices use a nanofibrous stationary phase with fiber diameters that are 400 nm. Separations of mixtures of laser dyes and mixtures of steroidal compounds were performed to illustrate the capabilities of these new UTLC media. The complete analyses were found to require very little development time and require less solvent than typical TLC methods. The efficiency of the separations was substantially improved compared to that determined using commercial phases. The retention properties and efficiency of the technique are discussed as are the effects of mat thickness and mobile phase composition on the chromatographic properties of the devices.

Ultrathin layer chromatography on nanostructured thin films

Ultrathin layer chromatography (UTLC) is a relatively new variant of thin layer chromatography, with a 10 μ m thick monolithic silica sorbent layer that gives faster separations with lower limits of detection and reduced analyte and solvent volumes. We have produced UTLC plates with controllable nanostructure and thickness, and show that the layer separation characteristics depends on the film nanostructure. We also show that layers made with in-plane anisotropic nanostructures will exhibit a decoupling effect, where the analyte spots do not develop in the same direction as the solvent front movement. The added layer morphology and material selection adds a degree of freedom to UTLC, and may have applications in multi-dimensional TLC.

Two-Dimensional Ultra-Thin-Layer Chromatography and Atmospheric Pressure Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Mass Spectrometry in Bioanalysis

The feasibility of ultra-thin-layer chromatography (UTLC) and atmospheric pressure matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (AP-MALDI-MS) for bioanalysis was studied with benzodiazepines as model substances in human urine. Two-dimensional (2D) UTLC was shown to be an efficient technique for the separation of benzodiazepines. Separations occurred in 4-12 min, and the separated compounds were identified by AP-MALDI-MS. The limits of detection with AP-MALDI-MS and AP-MALDI-MS/MS were in the picomole range and thus low enough for bioanalysis. The applicability of the 2D UTLC-AP-MALDI-MS was demonstrated in detection of metabolites with an authentic biological urine sample.

Analysis of ropinirole in tablet dosage form

Two simple methods, ultra violet spectroscopy and high performance thin layer chromatography for the determination of ropinirole in tablet dosage form are described. Detection wave lengths for spectrophotometric and high performance thin layer chromatographic methods were found to be 250 nm and 254 nm, respectively. For the spectrophotometric method, the linearity was found to be in the range of 5-30 mg/ml and for high performance thin layer chromatographic method; linearity was found to be between 40 and 120 mg/ml.

New surfaces for desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry: porous silicon and ultra‐thin layer chromatography plates

The performance of nanoporous silicon (pSi) and ultra-thin layer chromatography (UTLC) plates as surfaces for desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) was compared with that of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), both popular surfaces in previous DESI studies. The limits of detection (LODs) and other analytical characteristics for six different test compounds were determined using all four surfaces. The LODs for the compounds were in the fmol-pmol (pg-ng) range. The LODs with the pSi surface were further improved for each of the compounds when heat was applied to the surface during sample application which gave LODs as low as or lower than those achieved with PMMA and PTFE. The UTLC plates were successfully used as a rapid means of chromatographic separation prior to DESI-MS analysis. Another advantage achieved using the newer pSi and UTLC surfaces was increased speed of analysis, associated with drying of solution-phase samples. This took place immediately at the UTLC surface and it could be achieved rapidly by gently heating the pSi surface. The presence of salts in the sample did not cause suppression of the analyte signal with any of the surfaces.

Analysis of Small Molecules by Ultra Thin-Layer Chromatography-Atmospheric Pressure Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Mass Spectrometry

The feasibility of ultra thin-layer chromatography atmospheric pressure matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry (UTLC-AP-MALDI-MS) has been studied in the analysis of small molecules. Because of a thinner adsorbent layer, the monolithic UTLC plates provide 10-100 times better sensitivity in MALDI analysis than conventional high performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) plates. The limits of detection down to a low picomole range are demonstrated by UTLC-AP-MALDI-MS. Other advantages of UTLC over HPTLC include faster separations and lower solvent consumption. The performances of AP-MALDI-MS and vacuum MALDI-MS have been compared in the analysis of small drug molecules directly from the UTLC plates. The desorption from the irregular surface of UTLC plates with an external AP-MALDI ion source combined with an ion trap instrument provides clearly less variation in measurements of m/z values when compared with a vacuum MALDI-time-of-flight (TOF) instrument. The performance of the UTLC-AP-MALDI-MS method has been applied successfully to the purity analysis of synthesis products produced by solid-phase parallel synthesis method.

Ultra thin-layer chromatography

Ultra thin-layer chromatography plates (UTLC) with a monolithic structure of the stationary silica gel phase open up a new dimension in modern planar chromatography. The extremely small layer thickness of 10 μm and the absence of any kind of a binder lead, in combination with the structure of this stationary phase, to new and improved properties of the UTLC silica gel plates. The advantages of these UTLC plates are the short migration distances in the range of 1–3 cm, the short development times as well as the very low consumption of solvents as mobile phases in combination with high separation efficiency and sensitivity.