The processing conditions were varied during the production of polycarbonate-based composites with the multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) Baytubes® C150 P (Bayer MaterialScience AG, Leverkusen, Germany), by melt mixing with an extruder on a laboratory scale. These included the screw design, rotation speed, throughput, feeding position and MWCNT content. Particular attention was paid to the shortening of the MWCNT length as a function of the conditions mentioned. It was found that there is a correlation between the applied specific mechanical energy (SME) during the melt mixing process and MWCNT dispersion, which was quantified by the agglomerate area ratio of the non-dispersed nanotubes based on optical microscopic analysis. The higher the SME value, the lower this ratio, which indicates better dispersion. Above an SME value of about 0.4 kWh/kg, no further improvement in dispersion was achieved. The MWCNT length, as measured by the quantitative analysis of TEM images of the MWCNTs dissolved from the composites, decreased with the SME value down to values of 44% of the original MWCNT length. At a constant loading of 3 wt.%, the tensile strength and tensile modulus were almost independent of the SME, while the elongation at break and notched impact strength showed an increasing trend. The variation in the feeding position showed that feeding the MWCNTs into a side feeder led to slightly better electrical and mechanical properties for both types of MWCNTs studied (Baytubes® C150 P and Nanocyl™ NC7000 (Nanocyl S.A., Sambreville, Belgium)). However, feeding into the hopper led to better CNT dispersion with Baytubes® C150 P, while this was the case with Nanocyl™ NC7000 when feeding into the side feeder. The screw profile had an influence on the dispersion, the MWCNT length and the electrical resistance, but only to a small extent. Distributive screws led to a greater shortening of the MWCNT length than dispersive screws. By varying the MWCNT content, it was shown that a greater MWCNT shortening occurred at higher loadings. Two-stage masterbatch dilution leads to stronger shortening than composite production with direct MWCNT incorporation.