A comprehensive study is carried out to investigate the sensitivity of various combinations between cumulus (CU) and microphysics (MP) schemes using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model for simulating Extreme Rainfall Events (EREs) over the hilly terrain of Nagaland (25.1 oN – 27.2 oN; 93.2 oE– 95.3 °E). The study explores fifty-four distinct simulation combinations resulting from six CU and nine MP schemes. The simulated rainfall is compared with ground-based rain gauge network and Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) satellite observations. The investigation focuses primarily on finding the optimal CU-MP scheme combination based on spatiotemporal precision achieved by the identified schemes. The C14 (New Simplified Arakawa Schubert) cumulus scheme is found to be the optimum individual CU scheme. Similarly, the M14 (WDM5) microphysics scheme performs as the optimum individual MP scheme. The study highlights the significance of evaluating the performance of combined schemes over individual ones. Among the fifty-four combinations, sensitivity analysis identified six top-performing combinations, out of which the C11-M8 (Multiscale Kain Fritsch - New Thompson) combination stands out to be optimum with a robust correlation coefficient (CC) of 0.75, lower standard deviation (STD) of 0.76 mm, and RMSD of 0.51 mm. A variation in lead/lag time is found to vary from (−) 3.2 to (+) 5.0 h, with a median value of (+) 1.3 h, suggesting that, on average, the model tends to predict the occurrence of peak rainfall events slightly earlier than observed one. The absolute difference in latitudes (longitudes) of peak rainfall variation ranges from 0.42o - 0.8o (0 o - 0.51o) with a median value of 0.66o (0.37o), indicating that the model could better represent the longitudinal peak rainfall positions with notable accuracy. The spatial correlation coefficient (SCC) ranges between 0.31 and 0.68 with a median value of 0.50. From the overall analysis, it is also found that double moment MP schemes (New Thompson, Morrison (2 M), WDM5, WDM6) consistently perform better than the single moment MP schemes (Kessler, Lin et al., WSM3, WSM5, WSM6), whether in combination with CU schemes or individually. Spatiotemporal variations observed across different cases underscore the pivotal role of accurate topography representation in complex terrains, emphasizing the significance of terrain data in shaping rainfall patterns.
Read full abstract