We present a novel social choice theory based multi-criteria decision making method under neutrosophic environment and a new form of truth representation of neutrosophic theory called Distributed Indeterminacy Form (DIF). Our hybrid method consists of classical methods and an aggregation operator used in social choice theory. In addition to this, we also use DIF function to provide a more sensitive indeterminacy approach towards accuracy functions. We also consider reciprocal property for all individuals. This provides, as in intuitionistic fuzzy decision making theory, a consistent decision making for each individual. The solution approach presented in this paper in group decision making is treated under neutrosophic individual preference relations. These new approaches seem to be more consistent with natural human behaviour, hence should be more plausible and feasible. Moreover, the use of a similar approach to develop some deeper soft degrees of consensus is outlined. Finally, we give a Python implementation of our work in the Appendix section.