Blending conjugated polymers with insulating matrices is often utilized for engineering extrinsic properties in organic electronics. Semiconductor/insulator blends are typically processed to form a uniformly distributed network of conductive domains within the insulating matrix, marrying electronic and physical properties from individual components. Understanding of polymer-polymer interactions in such systems is thus crucial for property co-optimization. One of the commonly overlooked parameters is the structural configuration of the insulator on the resulting properties, especially the electronic properties. This study investigated how the tacticity of the matrix polymer, among other relevant parameters in play, impacts solid state crystallization in semiconductor/matrix blends and hence the resulting charge transport properties. We found an intricate dependence of the film morphology, aggregation behavior, electronic charge transport, and mixed ionic-electronic coupling properties on the insulator's tacticity. Our experimentally iterative approach shows that for a given application, when selecting semiconductor/insulator combinations, the tacticity of the matrix can be leveraged to optimize performance and vary solid-state structure.