SEER, 98, 1, JANUARY 2020 188 Zeller, Manfred. Sport and Society in the Soviet Union: The Politics of Football after Stalin. Translation by Nicki Challenger. The Library of Modern Russia. I. B. Tauris, London and New York, 2018. xx + 300 pp. Illustrations. Notes. List of source documents. Bibliography. Index. £75.00: $110.00. Manfred Zeller’s monograph on Soviet football fan culture, originally published in German, has now been translated and published in English. The book aims to provide a broad analysis of Soviet football fan culture in the post-World War Two period. This is a much needed study that explores various aspects of Soviet fan culture previously neglected by both Russian and Western scholars. Chapter one gives an account of current research on fan culture and spectator sport in which Zeller concludes that the historiography of both is ‘in its infancy at an international level’ (p. 13). The rest of the chapter discusses sources, methodology and analysis. Zeller conducted in-depth interviews with thirty-two Soviet football fans who supported Soviet soccer teams from the 1950s to the 1980s, and carried out significant archival research in Moscow and Kiev, in the Central State Archive of the City of Moscow, the State Archive of the Russian Federation, the Central State Archives of Public Organizations of Ukraine and the Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine. He was given access to Soviet Sport Committee documents, to numerous football referees’ reports, and to thousands of soccer fan letters in which they congratulated their favourite teams, requested that their local team be promoted to a higher league, complained about incorrect decisions by referees, criticized TV and radio soccer commentators, etc. In addition various articles about football, soccer fan letters and public statements made by the USSR Sports Committee that were published in the daily newspaper, Sovetskii Sport, and the by-weekly magazine Futbol proved to be valuable sources. Chapter two describes the fan rivalry between the Moscow teams Dinamo, Spartak and TsDKA in the 1930s to 1950s. Following research by Robert Edelman, Zeller analyses the almost universal popularity amongst Muscovites of Spartak Moscow — ‘the team of the people’ which they rooted for regardless of their professional affiliation. Zeller writes about the iconic role of Nikolai Starostin and his brother in managing and promoting the team. The bitter rivalry between Spartak and Dinamo; the attempts of Lavrentii Beria to arrest the Starostin brothers in order to prop up Dinamo, and the new image of Spartak as a representative of the victims of the Stalin purges are covered from various angles and with many interesting details. The fan interviews indicate that in the post-World War Two period many Moscow bolelshiki rooted for TsDKA: the stands were full of former officers and soldiers, as they identified ‘the army team’ with Soviet war victories more than did the fans of Dinamo, REVIEWS 189 the police team. The chapter then zooms in on the defeat of the Soviet national soccer team, mostly consisting of TsDKA players, at the Olympics in 1952 which led to the disbanding of TsDKA by the USSR Sports Committee — one of Stalin’s last gestures in the world of Soviet sports. Several of the interviewees were old enough to witness these events and provided their recollections. Chapter three mostly deals with stadium violence (rather mild by modern standards) in Moscow, Kiev and other Soviet cities in the 1950s and 1960s and the reaction of soccer fans and police, as well as party and Soviet authorities. It offers a convincing lexical and stylistic analysis of the Soviet fan chants, ‘Sudiu na mylo’ and ‘Sudia pederast’, indicating how difficult and sometimes dangerous the work of the soccer referees was, as many of them were attacked not just verbally but also by glass bottles and stones. This kind of behaviour was reported from every corner of the Soviet Union — Kiev, Donetsk, Poltava, Kishinev, Tbilisi, Yerevan, Tashkent, Leningrad and Moscow. Zeller reports that the famous football referee Nikolai Latyshev was beaten twice in separate incidents: in Tbilisi and in Moscow. Zeller’s data leads to a valid observation that ‘in the years after Stalin’s death […] football stadiums were the ideal...
Read full abstract