Mechanical properties of zinc-blende MgxZn1−xSyTe1−y alloys and cationic (Mg) and anionic (S) composition dependence of these properties have been investigated theoretically through First-principles calculations. The elastic stiffness constants increase nonlinearly with increasing sulfur concentration at each fixed magnesium concentration, while each of them reduces with increasing magnesium concentration at each fixed sulfur concentration in any binary–ternary/ternary–quaternary system. Hardness of specimens increases nonlinearly with increasing sulfur concentration at each fixed magnesium concentration, while it reduces with increasing magnesium concentration at each fixed sulfur concentration in any binary–ternary/ternary–quaternary system. Each of the considered specimens is mechanically stable, ductile, elastically anisotropic, fairly compressible and plastic in nature. Blending of covalent and ionic bonding with domination of covalent, bending over stretching in chemical bonds and central character of force between atoms have been observed in each specimen. Computed Debye temperature confirms MgS as the hardest and ZnTe as the softest among all the considered specimens. Computed Gruneisen parameter of each specimen demonstrates anharmonic character of atom–atom interactions in each crystal. Thermal conductivity and melting temperature of each of the considered specimens have also been computed in the present study.