Objective. To examine whether higher use of non-invasive testing with stress testing or cardiac computed tomographic angiography increases the diagnostic yield of elective coronary angiography as assessed by subsequent revascularization. Background. Many patients who undergo elective coronary angiography are found not have obstructive coronary disease, yet prior non-invasive testing is often underused. Increasing the use of non-invasive testing prior to elective coronary angiography may improve its diagnostic yield through better selection of candidates for subsequent coronary revascularization. Methods. Using a complete sample of billing claims from a national health insurer, (Aetna) we identified adults≥35 years who underwent elective coronary angiography from January 1, 2008 to September 30, 2009. We first conducted a patient-level propensity-matched analysis to determine the relationship between non-invasive testing with revascularization. We also conducted a regional-level analysis examining geographic variation in non-invasive testing and revascularization rates across U.S. hospital referral regions (HRRs). Results. Overall, 33,429 out of 62,501 (53.5%) patients who underwent elective coronary angiography had non-invasive testing performed within 90 days, the majority undergoing myocardial perfusion imaging (n=29,634). In a matched propensity analysis that adjusted for patient characteristics, prior non-invasive testing was associated with a modestly lower likelihood of subsequent revascularization within 90 days (10.0% v 11.1%, p<0.0001). Across 241 HRRs, we observed substantial regional variation in the use of non-invasive testing prior to coronary angiography (median 52.5%, range 26.3-84.8%), and subsequent revascularization (median 10.8%, range 0-34.6%). However, regional variation in the non-invasive testing rate explained essentially none of the variation in revascularization rates (adjusted r-squared=0.04). Conclusion. Non-invasive testing prior to elective coronary angiography was not associated with increased revascularization in either patient-level or regional-level analyses. Efforts to improve the diagnostic yield of elective coronary angiography by increasing prior use of non-invasive testing may be limited in real-world settings.
Read full abstract