The short transverse fracture toughness of an Al–Li–Cu–Mg–Zr extrudate was determined as a function of aging condition and testing temperature. To elucidate the underlying micromechanisms, the short transverse fracture surfaces of the extrudate were characterised via scanning electron microscopy, grain boundary precipitates and precipitation free zones were identified via transmission electron microscopy, and segregation of elements to grain boundaries was analysed using secondary ion mass spectrometry. Three principal observations were made as follows. First, with increasing aging time, the short transverse toughness of the extrudate increased when tested at room temperature, but decreased at liquid N2 temperature, whereas with decreasing testing temperature, it remained essentially constant for the underaged condition, and decreased sharply for the peak aged and overaged tempers. Second, in addition to regions exhibiting shallow dimples, smooth ‘featureless’ zones were revealed on the short transverse fracture surfaces, which are intergranular in nature for all the specimens tested. The area fraction of the featureless regions decreased noticeably with increasing aging time when tested at room temperature, and increased markedly with decreasing testing temperature for the peak aged and overaged conditions. Third, segregation of Li, Si, Na, and H was detected for both the underaged and overaged specimens, and also of K for the underaged specimens only. In general, the enhancement of the room temperature short transverse toughness with aging and the negative effect of cryogenic temperature on fracture toughness are in obvious contrast to the in plane toughness behaviour reported in the literature, the featureless character of the short transverse fracture and its connection with poor toughness seldom having been emphasised. Based upon the present study, segregation induced brittleness is proposed as the critical micromechanism responsible for grain boundary weakness, and thus for the poor short transverse fracture toughness.MST/1829