Water electrolysis is an important route toward sustainable industrial production of hydrogen, as well as mitigation of the CO2 emissions associated with current hydrogen production from natural gas. The industrial deployment of clean electrolytic hydrogen will depend on long-term electrolyzer durability under the intermittent operating conditions associated with coupling with renewable sources of electricity. Thus, understanding cell degradation mechanisms is required to develop mitigation strategies and minimize performance degradation over extended periods of operation.Here, we investigate the effect of temperature and intermittent conditions on proton exchange membrane (PEM) water electrolyzer performance over a variety of timescales. Performance losses consisting of both reversible losses and irreversible degradation accelerate quickly during holds at high current densities and low temperatures, reaching high cell voltages within several hours. However, the cell can be returned to near beginning-of-test performance by interrupting these current holds with a variety of intermittent states of operation, such as interruption of the applied current or operation at higher temperatures. Reversible losses can harm the overall cell efficiency without being captured in short-term polarization curves, and may also contribute to stressors causing long-term degradation. The impact of different shut-down and idle states on the catalyst layers and cell degradation will also be discussed. The presented insights could contribute to the development of accelerated stress test protocols as well as performance recovery strategies for long-term operation of PEM water electrolyzers.