Thiel replies: When thinking about potential toxicity, which Neal Reid mentions, it’s key to remember that almost all the material in the brine originated in the ocean. Nevertheless, ensuring environmentally friendly disposal continues to be an active area of research, and modern outfalls are very effective at dispersing the brine flow so as to minimize local increases in the concentration of salts and other dissolved compounds. A study for the Carlsbad desalination project in California concluded that properly designed outfalls have “impacts that extend only a few tens of meters from the discharge.”11. S. Jenkins et al., Management of Brine Discharges to Coastal Waters: Recommendations of a Science Advisory Panel, tech. rep. 694, Southern California Coastal Water Research Project (March 2012), p. ii. The Carlsbad plant also mixes the reverse-osmosis brine with seawater used for cooling a colocated power plant prior to discharge, which reduces its salinity before it hits the ocean. And as for the comparison to nuclear waste, let’s not forget that the diffusion time for the salt in the disposed brine is orders of magnitude less than the half-life of radioactive waste!To answer Jonathan Allen’s concern, the kWhe values given for the evaporative systems are exergetic values of the heat input. That approach uses the Carnot efficiency between the desalination system’s top temperature, which often reaches 70 °C, and an ambient temperature of 25 °C to convert between heat and work. The cost of the thermal energy input itself may be less than for electricity, but the costs associated with constructing, for example, a solar-thermal collector or a heat exchanger required to use waste heat can be significant. Lower energy consumption may not imply lower cost, but reverse osmosis is far and away the dominant choice of recent installed desalination capacity.Desalination powered by renewable energy is a topic of great interest to many in the desalination community—myself included!REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. S. Jenkins et al., Management of Brine Discharges to Coastal Waters: Recommendations of a Science Advisory Panel, tech. rep. 694, Southern California Coastal Water Research Project (March 2012), p. ii. Google Scholar© 2015 American Institute of Physics.
Read full abstract