Searches are compulsory actions carried out on certain places, objects, or persons to discover specific objects or persons. The Constitution stipulates due process and warrant principles for searches related to compulsory dispositions. The Criminal Procedure Act also stipulates due process and warrant principles to ensure that searches are conducted in accordance with legal procedures and methods, and it also provides for exceptions to the warrant requirement. There are no explicit provisions allowing for consent searches. However, they are commonly conducted in investigative practice because they are more procedurally simple and efficient than searches conducted with warrants. There is a risk of abuse of consent searches as a means of circumventing or avoiding the warrant principle. The question is whether consent searches are permissible in light of the due process provisions, warrant principles, and exceptions to the warrant principle in the Constitution and Criminal Procedure Act. Consent searches are considered permissible as a voluntary investigative method as long as voluntary consent is guaranteed. Even if consent searches are generally permissible, legal requirements must be strictly established to prevent abuse. A search based on consent is lawful if a person capable of consent gives voluntary consent and the search is conducted within the scope of that consent. Whether the investigative agency must inform the person of their right to refuse consent is a matter of debate. While the notification of the right to refuse consent is not an absolute standard for determining voluntariness, it is an important factor to consider. If consent is given after being informed of the right to refuse, it is more likely to be considered voluntary. In criminal proceedings, the issue arises of how to determine the legality of a consent search. The burden of proving the legality of a consent search lies with the prosecutor, and any disadvantage in cases where the truth is unknown must fall on the prosecutor. The legality of a consent search can be proven through free proof as a legal fact, but the degree of proof must be sufficient to exclude reasonable doubt. When the legality of a consent search is contested, the decision should be based on whether the legality has been clearly proven by objective circumstances.
Read full abstract