Concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CRT) is the gold standard in management of limited-stage small cell lung cancer (LS-SCLC). Local therapy with surgery or stereotactic radiotherapy (SBRT), followed by adjuvant chemotherapy may be appropriate in patients with very early (T1-T2, N0) disease. This study aimed to determine practice patterns for very early LS-SCLC among lung cancer specialists in Canada. A survey was developed and distributed to Canadian medical and radiation oncologists specializing in lung cancer. The survey consisted of three sections: 1) physician demographics, 2) general practice approach, and 3) preferred approach for three clinical scenarios (1: a peripheral T1 lesion; 2: a central T1 lesion; 3: a peripheral T2 lesion). Responses were analyzed to detect differences in management across cases and among various physician groups. A total of 77 physicians participated. In case 1, when the patient was eligible for surgery, most respondents (73%) chose surgery with adjuvant chemotherapy as their preferred management, with only 19% choosing CRT. CRT was selected by a higher proportion in case 2 (48%) and case 3 (61%) (p<0.05). If medically operable, most chose CRT over SBRT and adjuvant chemotherapy in all cases. CRT was significantly more popular in case 2 (84%) and case 3 (86%) than in case 1 (55%) (p<0.05). Subgroup analysis showed physicians from Western Canadian were more likely to choose CRT, those from Ontario were more likely to offer SBRT, and those who have spent longer in practice were more likely to choose CRT over local therapy. There is no clear consensus regarding optimal management of patients with very early LS-SCLC among specialists in Canada, with significant variations in practice patterns. CRT remains the most popular strategy in most cases, with surgery and adjuvant chemotherapy preferred for small peripheral lesions. Increasing size of tumor as well as more central location are factors that drive physicians towards choosing CRT. Variation in practice is correlated to region of the country and to physician experience.
Read full abstract