Background: Appendicitis is one of the most frequent diagnoses for emergency department visits resulting in hospitalization. A number of scoring systems have been developed to try to identify people who are likely to have appendicitis and are eligible for surgery. Aim of study: is to compare the accuracy of RIPASA to Alvarado score in the diagnosis of acute appendicitis. Methods: A prospective comparative study that was conducted at Al-Yarmouk Teaching Hospital / Baghdad during the period of one year from 1st of Feb. 2019 till 1st of Feb. 2020. It included 200 patients attended the outpatient clinic or the emergency department in Al-Yarmouk Teaching Hospital complaining from lower abdominal and/or right iliac fossa pain suggestive of acute appendicitis. Scoring was done to diagnose appendicitis by two scoring systems (Alvarado and RIPASA) using the data for each patient. The individual scores were then compared to the final diagnosis made by the clinician and to the recommendations of each scoring system. Results: In this study, most of the patients (172 patients, 86%) underwent appendectomy. We noticed that 44.8% of the operated cases were diagnosed as catarrhal appendicitis. Incidences of rebound tenderness, leukocytosis, migratory pain, ROVSING sign, and right iliac fossa guarding were significantly higher in patients diagnosed with appendicitis than those in patients diagnosed as normal appendix. Means of ALVARADO and RIPASA scores were significantly increased with severity to reach the highest level in patients diagnosed with severe appendicitis than other findings. ALVARADO score was 69.7% sensitive, 87.5% specific, and 74% accurate. RIPASA score was 94.1% sensitive, 62.5% specific, and 86.5% accurate. Conclusion: RIPASA score is more accurate and more sensitive than Alvarado score, in spite of the lower specificity, so that it can be effectively conducted for the better evaluation of acute appendicitis. RIPASA score is simple, non-invasive, and cost effective way to be used in resource limited conditions.
Read full abstract