Besides the common modes of failure including compressive, tensile, and bending in concrete structures, cracking and failure due to the shear is also considered as a significant and hazardous mode of failure. The shear failure mode can be observed in structural elements such as deep beams, locations having high point loads, connection cores of beams and concrete columns, short columns, punching shear in slabs and foundations, etc. However, the direct shear strength of the fiber-reinforced concretes has seen limited studied. Hereupon, this study aims to experimentally investigate the influences of the type, length, and various volumetric fractions of the steel fiber (SF) and polypropylene (PP) fiber on the compressive strength, the tensile strength, and specifically on the direct shear strength of the fiber-reinforced concretes. To this end, four different mixture design schemes of the plain concrete were examined by adding PP and SF with lengths of 3 cm, 5 cm, and their half-half combination with volumetric fractions of 0.5 %, 1 %, and 1.5 % to measure the compressive strength (the cubic sample), the tensile strength (the cylindrical sample), and the direct shear strength (the prismatic sample) of the concrete specimens. In addition, the plain concrete specimens as the witness specimens were built to compare with fiber-reinforced ones. The experiments were not only performed for 20–25 MPa concrete strength category, but were also executed for 25–30 MPa. The constructed concrete specimens were exhaustively surveyed in terms of the contribution of the fibers, the failure patterns in various specimens, the force-displacement diagrams in shear, the maximum displacement in specimens, the aspect ratio of the fibers, and the shear ductility index in various specimens. The obtained results indicated that, with increasing the length and volumetric fraction of the fibers (i.e., the aspect ratios), the compressive, tensile, and direct shear strengths have been subsequently augmented in the concrete specimens. Moreover, the strain and ductility of the concrete specimens have also been enhanced. Remarkably, in most tests, the SF-reinforced specimens have excellent performance compared with other specimens. However, the specimens containing the PP fibers have not considerably improved the compressive and direct shear strengths of the concrete specimens.