Open-shell Triplet Research Articles

Mechanistic insights into the formation of oxenium ions and radical intermediates through the photolysis of phenylhydroxylamine and its derivatives.

The photolysis of photoprecursors to produce oxenium ions has been the subject of extensive experimental studies from femtosecond to microsecond time scales. However, mechanistic insights into the generation of activated intermediate species remain elusive. Herein, we present a theoretical investigation to comprehensively elucidate the possible reaction channels for the formation of oxenium ions and radical intermediates at the multi-configuration perturbation level of theory. Computational results show that photo-initiated electron donation from the phenyl moiety to the repulsive N-O σ* orbital leads to the formation of a diradical intermediate in ground state, and further triggers intramolecular electron transfer from the phenyl moiety to the ammonia radical cation (˙NH3+). This affords closed-shell singlet oxenium ions and neutral :NH3 as the major products. However, the generation of open-shell triplet outcomes is shown to rely on the energetically accessible single-triplet crossings and spin-orbital interaction among the involved electronic states. Taken together, these data can be used to determine the electronic structures and related properties, as well as reactivities, of oxenium ions and radicals generated by the photolysis of phenylhydroxylamine and its derivatives.

Stable Organic Neutral Diradical via Reversible Coordination.

We report the formation of a stable neutral diboron diradical simply by coordination of an aromatic dinitrogen compound to an ortho-phenyldiborane. This process is reversible upon addition of pyridine. The diradical species is stable above 200 °C. Computations are consistent with an open-shell triplet diradical with a very small open-shell singlet-triplet energy gap that is indicative of the electronic disjointness of the two radical sites. This opens a new way of generating stable radicals with fascinating electronic properties useful for a large variety of applications.

Structures and Physical Properties of Chemically Reduced Diindenosiloles and Their π-Extended Derivatives

Diindenosilole Si1, a silicon-bridged fulvalene derivative, was successfully reduced to its dianions using various alkali metals, and the structures were characterized by X-ray crystallographic analysis. Radical anions of Si1 as well as dianions of π-extended Si3 could also be synthesized, and the structural and physical properties were systematically compared. It was also found that the NMR spectra of dianions Si12– and Si32– show countercation and temperature dependency for their signal broadness, indicating the possible existence of thermal interconversion between closed-shell singlet states and open-shell triplet states.

Rhodium Complexes Promoting C-O Bond Formation in Reactions with Oxygen: The Role of Superoxo Species.

C-O bond formation in reactions of olefins with oxygen is a long standing challenge in chemistry for which the very complicated-sometimes controversial-mechanistic panorama slows down the design of catalysts for oxygenations. In this regard, the mechanistic details of the oxidation of the complex [Rh(cod)(Ph2 N3 )] (1) (cod=1,5-cyclooctadiene) with oxygen to the unique 2-rhodaoxetane compound [{Rh(OC8 H12 )(Ph2 N3 )}2 ] (2) has been investigated by DFT calculations. The results of this study provide evidences for a novel bimetallic mechanism in which two rhodium atoms redistribute the four electrons involved in the cleavage of the O=O bond. Furthermore, both oxygen atoms are used to create two new C-O bonds in a controlled fashion with 100 % atom economy. The key intermediates that we have found in this process are a mononuclear open-shell triplet superoxo compound, an open-shell singlet "μ-(peroxo)" derivative, and a closed-shell singlet "bis(μ-oxo)" complex. Some of the findings are used to predict the reactions of RhI complexes with oxygen, exemplified by that of the complex [Rh(cod)(OnapyMe2 )] (3). Starting from 3, [{Rh(OC8 H12 )(OnapyMe2 )}2 ] (4) has been prepared and characterized, which represents the second example of a 2-rhodaoxetane compound coming from an oxygenation reaction with oxygen.

Anion-induced exchange interactions in binuclear complexes of Cu(II) with flexible hexadentate bispicolylamidrazone ligands

Two recently synthesized copper(II) complexes with spacer-armed bispicolylamidrazone ligands have been theoretically studied at the density functional theory (DFT) level accounting for empirical dispersion correction and intrinsic anionic environment by perchlorate ions. The exchange parameter between the open-shell singlet and triplet states of the studied complexes has been estimated by broken symmetry DFT calculations. The mechanism of spin-spin exchange interaction between the unpaired electrons via the σ-bond aliphatic chain (Gusev et al., 2015) is confirmed. Instead, a anion-induced mechanism is proposed which means that the anionic grid participates in the exchange interaction between the unpaired electrons.

Möbius–Hückel Topology Switching in Expanded Porphyrins: EPR, ENDOR, and DFT Studies of Doublet and Triplet Open-Shell Systems

The one-sided Mobius band topology with its characteristic 180° twist has fascinated and inspired philosophers, artists and scientists since a long time. On the molecular level, only in the last 13 years a few chemistry groups succeeded to artificially create novel compounds with Mobius symmetry by theory-based molecular design and elaborate chemical synthesis. The interest in molecules with Mobius band symmetry was greatly stimulated in 1964 by a theoretical paper by Edgar Heilbronner from the ETH Zurich. He predicted that sufficiently large [n]annulenes with a closed-shell electron configuration of 4n π-electrons should allow for sufficient π-overlap stabilization to be synthesizable by twisting them into the Mobius topology of their hydrocarbon skeleton. In 2003, the first synthesis of an aromatic Mobius annulene was accomplished by Rainer Herges and co-workers in Kiel. In 2007, Lechoslaw Latos-Grazynski and co-workers in Wroclaw succeeded in synthesizing free-base di-p-benzi (Yoneda et al., Angew Chem Int Ed 53: 13169–13173, 2014) hexaphyrin (1.1.1.1.1.1), compound 1, an expanded porphyrin which can dynamically switch between Huckel and Mobius conjugation upon changes of solvent and temperature. Shortly thereafter, in 2008, Atsuhiro Osuka and his co-workers from Kyoto, Seoul and Hyogo published the synthesis of an expanded porphyrin in which metalation triggered the production of molecular twisting and Mobius aromaticity. In this minireview, among other studies also our recent EPR, ENDOR and DFT studies on open-shell states of 1, i.e., on the ground-state radical cation doublet state (total electron spin S = 1/2) and the first excited triplet state (S = 1) are summarized. The review is largely based on a previous joint publication of the current authors with the Latos-Grazynski group on radical cations of 1 (Mobius et al., Phys Chem Chem Phys 17:6644–6652, 2015). The radical cation study was the first one of an open-shell π-system with Mobius topology. In the doublet state, the hyperfine interactions of the unpaired electron spin with specific magnetic nuclei in the molecule was used as a sensitive probe for the electronic structure of the molecule and its symmetry properties. This work has now been extended to state-of-the-art DFT theory studies on photo-excited triplet states of 1. In the open-shell triplet state, besides hyperfine couplings, a change of the zero-field splitting interaction between the two unpaired electron spins is predicted to be a viable sensor for electronic structure changes upon Mobius-to-Huckel topology switching.

Hydrogenase biomimetics with redox-active ligands: Electrocatalytic proton reduction by [Fe2(CO)4(κ2-diamine)(μ-edt)] (diamine = 2,2′-bipy, 1,10-phen)

Diiron complexes bearing redox active diamine ligands have been studied as models of the active site of [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Heating [Fe2(CO)6(μ-edt)] (edt=1,2-ethanedithiolate) with 2,2′-bipyridine (2,2′-bipy) or 1,10-phenanthroline (1,10-phen) in MeCN in the presence of Me3NO leads to the formation of [Fe2(CO)4(κ2-2,2′-bipy)(μ-edt)] (1-edt) and [Fe2(CO)4(κ2-1,10-phen)(μ-edt)] (2-edt), respectively, in moderate yields. In the solid state the diamine resides in dibasal sites, while both dibasal and apical–basal isomers are present in solution. Both stereoisomers protonate readily upon addition of strong acids. Cyclic voltammetry in MeCN shows that both complexes undergo irreversible oxidation and reduction, proposed to be a one- and two-electron process, respectively. The structures of neutral 2-edt and its corresponding one- and two-electron reduced species have been investigated by DFT calculations. In 2-edt− the added electron occupies a predominantly ligand-based orbital, and the iron–iron bond is maintained, being only slightly elongated. Addition of the second electron affords an open-shell triplet dianion where the second electron populates an Fe–Fe σ* antibonding orbital, resulting in effective scission of the iron–iron bond. The triplet state lies 4.2kcalmol−1 lower in energy than the closed-shell singlet dianion whose HOMO correlates nicely with the LUMO of the neutral species 2-edt. Electrocatalytic proton reduction by both complexes has been studied in MeCN using CF3CO2H as the proton source. These catalysis studies reveal that while at high acid concentrations the active catalytic species is [Fe2(CO)4(μ-H)(κ2-diamine)(μ-edt)]+, at low acid concentrations the two complexes follow different catalytic mechanisms being associated with differences in their relative rates of protonation.

Theoretical estimation of the rate of photoinduced charge transfer reactions in triphenylamine C60 donor-acceptor conjugate.

Fullerene-based molecular heterojunctions such as the [6,6]-pyrrolidine-C60 donor-acceptor conjugate containing triphenylamine (TPA) are potential materials for high-efficient dye-sensitized solar cells. In this work, we estimate the rate constants for the photoinduced charge separation and charge recombination processes in TPA-C60 using the unrestricted and time-dependent DFT methods. Different schemes are applied to evaluate excited state properties and electron transfer parameters (reorganization energies, electronic couplings, and Gibbs energies). The use of open-shell singlet or triplet states, several density functionals, and continuum solvation models is discussed. Strengths and limitations of the computational approaches are highlighted. The present benchmark study provides an overview of the expected performance of DFT-based methodologies in the description of photoinduced charge transfer reactions in fullerene heterojunctions. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Ab initio coupled-cluster and multi-reference configuration interaction studies of the low-lying electronic states of 1,2,3,4-cyclobutanetetraone

ABSTRACTThe four, closely spaced, lowest energy electronic states of the challenging, D4h-symmetric, 1,2,3,4-cyclobutanetetraone (C4O4) molecule have been investigated using high-level ab initio methods. The calculated states include the closed-shell singlet 8π(1A1g) state, the singlet 10π(1A1g) state, in which the π-type lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the 8π(1A1g) reference is doubly occupied and the σ-type highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) is empty, and the open-shell singlet and triplet states, designated as 9π(1B2u) and 9π(3B2u), respectively, originating from single occupancy of the HOMO and LUMO. Our focus is on single-reference coupled-cluster (CC) approaches capable of handling electronic near-degeneracies in diradicals, especially the completely renormalised CR-CC(2,3) and active-space CCSDt methods, along with their CCSD and EOMCCSD counterparts. The internally contracted multi-reference configuration interaction calculations with a quasi-degenerate Davidson correction are performed as well. Our computations demonstrate that the state ordering is 9π(3B2u) < 8π(1A1g) < 9π(1B2u) < 10π(1A1g) and that the 8π(1A1g) − 9π(3B2u) gap is in the 7–11 kJ/mol range, in reasonable agreement with the negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy measurements, which give 6.27 ± 0.5 kJ/mol. In addition to the theory level used, geometry relaxation and basis set play a significant role in determining the state ordering and energy spacings. In particular, it is unsafe to use lower level, non-CC geometries and smaller basis sets.

Theoretical Designs for Fullerene Carbenes, C60–E–C60 and C70–E–C70 (E = Group 14 Elements): A Target for Experimental Studies

A density functional study of singlet and triplet state fullerene carbenes is performed, using the M06-2X/CRENBL ECP, M06-2X/Def2-SV(P), and M06-2X/LANL2DZ levels of theory. The structures of two model carbenes (C60–E–C60 and C70–E–C70; E = C, Si, Ge, Sn, and Pb) in their closed-shell singlet and open-shell triplet states are obtained. The theoretical computations suggest that the formation of C60–E–C60 should be energetically more feasible than that of C70-E-C70 (E = C, Si, and Ge). In particular, the C70–E–C70 species with tin and lead should be relatively difficult to produce, from the viewpoint of bonding dissociation energy. The theoretical evidence also suggests that the bulky substituents that occupy the inner side of C60–E–C60 and C70–E–C70 should make the triplet ground state easily achievable. These theoretical findings show that both the relativistic effect and steric effect play an essential role in determining the electronic states of fullerene carbenes.

A fine line separates carbocations from diradical ions in donor-unconjugated cations.

Carbocations are traditionally thought to be closed-shell electrophiles featuring an empty orbital rich in p character. Here, density functional theory computations indicate that when strong π donors are not placed in direct conjugation with benzylic-type cations, alternative diradical configurations that resemble non-Kekulé diradicals are possible. For certain donor-acceptor frameworks, an open-shell singlet configuration is the computed ground state for the cation, whereas for coumarin and xanthenyl cations substituted with strong donors, a triplet diradical configuration is the computed ground state. Changing the substituent nature and attachment location substantially alters the energy gaps between the different electronic configurations and can manipulate the computed ground-state electronic configuration. There are few known examples of ground-state triplet carbocations, and, to our knowledge, no other examples of open-shell singlet carbocations. The open-shell singlet and triplet "carbocations" described here may have reactivity distinct from that of typical closed-shell singlet carbocations and, if appropriately stabilized, lead to organic materials with interesting electronic and magnetic properties.

Direct spectroscopic observation of closed-shell singlet, open-shell singlet, and triplet p-biphenylyloxenium ion.

The photophysics and photochemistry of p-biphenylyl hydroxylamine hydrochloride was studied using laser flash photolysis ranging from the femtosecond to the microsecond time scale. The singlet excited state of this photoprecursor is formed within 350 fs and partitions into three different transients that are assigned to the p-biphenyloxy radical, the open-shell singlet p-biphenylyloxenium ion, and the triplet p-biphenylyloxenium ion, having lifetimes of 40 μs, 45 ps, and 1.6 ns, respectively, in CH3CN. The open-shell singlet p-biphenylyloxenium ion predominantly undergoes internal conversion to produce the closed-shell singlet p-biphenylyloxenium ion, which has a lifetime of 5-20 ns. The longer-lived radical is unambiguously assigned by nanosecond time-resolved resonance Raman (ns-TR(3)) spectroscopy, and the assignment of the short-lived singlet and triplet oxenium ion transient absorptions are supported by matching time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) predictions of the absorptions of these species, as well as by product studies that implicate the intermediacy of charged electrophilic intermediates. Product studies from photolysis give p-biphenylol as the major product and a chloride adduct as the major product when NaCl is added as a trap. Thermolysis studies give p-biphenylol as a major product, as well as water, ammonium, and chloro adducts. These studies provide a rare direct look at a discrete oxenium ion intermediate and the first detection of open-shell singlet and triplet configurations of an oxenium ion, as well as providing an intriguing example of the importance of excited state dynamics in governing the electronic state population of reactive intermediates.

Weakening of the π*–π* dimerisation in 1,2,3,5-dithiadiazolyl radicals: structural, EPR, magnetic and computational studies of dichlorophenyl dithiadiazolyls, Cl2C6H3CNSSN

A series of dichlorophenyl dithiadiazolyls (DCP-DTDA) have been prepared and structurally characterized by X-ray diffraction (1 = 2,3-DCP-DTDA; 2 = 2,4-DCP-DTDA; 3 = 2,5-DCP-DTDA, 4 = 3,4-DCP-DTDA and 5 = 3,5-DCP-DTDA). All the radicals adopt cis-cofacial π*–π* dimers with intra-dimer S⋯S contacts in the range 3.119(8)–3.300(5) A. The propensity for chloro-aromatics to adopt a β-sheet structure assists formation of lamellar structures in 1–5 with intra-stack Cl⋯Cl contacts in the range 3.44(1)–3.82(1) A. Perpendicular to the stacking direction, the packing is dominated by formation of intermolecular S⋯Cl contacts. Variable-temperature magnetic susceptibility measurements on 1–5 in the range 5–300 K reveal the onset of paramagnetism around ca. 200 K. Solid-state EPR studies reveal that this paramagnetism is associated with thermal population of a triplet excited state. A good fit to the Bleaney–Bowers model determined the exchange interactions (2J) between the radicals in the dimers to be in the range −904 to −1529 cm−1. Computational studies of the dimerisation process indicate that at intra-dimer S⋯S distances in excess of 3.2 A the closed-shell singlet becomes destabilized with respect to both the open-shell singlet and triplet state configurations.

Interaction of Various Gas Molecules with Paddle-Wheel-Type Open Metal Sites of Porous Coordination Polymers: Theoretical Investigation

We theoretically evaluated binding energies (Eb's) between various gas molecules and the Cu center open metal site (Cu-OMS) of Cu paddle-wheel units, [Cu2(O2CR)4] (R = H, Me, or Ph) using density functional theory (DFT) and MP2-MP4. The optimized geometry of the model system [Cu2(O2CPh)4] agrees with the experimental structure. The Eb of CO with [Cu2(O2CH)4] is only slightly different between the open-shell singlet and triplet states. The calculated Eb decreases in the order MeNC > H2O > MeCN > C2H4 > C2H2 > CO > CO2 > N2 > CH4 > H2. The trend is discussed in terms of the electrostatic interaction energy (ES), exchange repulsion energy (EX), and charge-transfer (CT) + polarization (Pol) interaction energy at the Hartree-Fock level and the electron correlation effect. The ES increases linearly with an increase in Eb, while the EX decreases linearly with an increase in Eb. These relationships indicate that the ES compensates for the EX. In other words, the Eb does not depend on the sum of ES and EX, which corresponds to the static energy. The electron correlation effect contributes little to the above-mentioned decreasing order of Eb. The total Eb roughly increases with an increase in the CT+Pol term, suggesting that the CT+Pol term plays important roles in determining the trend of Eb. The shift of the stretching frequency of adsorbed gas molecules on the Cu-OMS is reproduced well by the DFT calculation with the model system [Cu2(O2CH)4(L)2] (L = gas molecule). We found that the positive charge on the Cu significantly contributes to the shift in the end-on coordination gas molecules such as CO, MeNC, MeCN, and N2. Although the shift has been generally discussed in terms of donation and back-donation, the present result indicates that the electrostatic potential field in the porous coordination polymer should be considered in the discussion of the frequency shift.

Pyrrole-Fused Azacoronene Family: The Influence of Replacement with Dialkoxybenzenes on the Optical and Electronic Properties in Neutral and Oxidized States

A novel pyrrole-fused azacoronene family was synthesized via oxidative cyclodehydrogenation of the corresponding hexaarylbenzenes as the key step, and the crystal structures of tetraazacoronene 3b and triazacoronene 4a were elucidated. The photophysical properties for neutral compounds 1-4 were investigated using steady-state UV-vis absorption/emission spectroscopy and time-resolved spectroscopy (emission spectra and lifetime measurements) at both room temperature and 77 K. The observation of both fluorescence and phosphorescence allowed us to estimate the small S1-T1 energy gap (ΔES-T) to be 0.35 eV (1a), 0.26 eV (2a), and 0.36 eV (4a). Similar to the case of previously reported hexapyrrolohexaazacoronene 1 (HPHAC), electrochemical oxidation revealed up to four reversible oxidation processes for all of the new compounds. The charge and spin delocalization properties of the series of azacoronene π-systems were examined using UV-vis-NIR absorption, ESR, and NMR spectroscopies for the chemically generated radical cations and dications. Combined with the theoretical calculations, the experimental results clearly demonstrated that the replacement of pyrrole rings with dialkoxybenzene plays a critical role in the electronic communication, where resonance structures significantly contribute to the thermodynamic stability of the cationic charges/spins and determine the spin multiplicities. For HPHAC 1 and pentaazacoronene 2, the overall aromaticity predicted for closed-shell dications 1(2+) and 2(2+) was primarily based on the theoretical calculations, and the open-shell singlet biradical or triplet character was anticipated for tetraazacoronene 3(2+) and triazacoronene 4(2+) with the aid of theoretical calculations. These polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) represent the first series of nitrogen-containing PAHs that can be multiply oxidized.

Open-Shell Triplet Character of #6094C68: Spherical Aromaticity, Thermodynamic Stability, and Regioselective Chlorination

The recently captured fullerene (#6094)C68 was found to exhibit a more aromatic character than originally assumed via density functional theory calculations. Such an inconsistency was attributed to the unexpected triplet ground state of pristine (#6094)C68. The equilibrium concentrations of C68 isomeric system reveal that (#6094)C68 is thermodynamically favorable at elevated temperatures with respect to the fullerene formation. The regioselective chlorination process of the open-shell C68 was discussed as well to elucidate the formation of octachlorinated derivative C68Cl8 experimentally.

Bonding Quandary in the [Cu3S2]3+Core: Insights from the Analysis of Domain Averaged Fermi Holes and the Local Spin

The electronic structure of the trinuclear symmetric complex [(tmedaCu)3S2 ](3+), whose Cu3S2 core represents a model of the active site of metalloenzymes involved in biological processes, has been in recent years the subject of vigorous debate. The complex exists as an open-shell triplet, and discussions concerned the question whether there is a direct S-S bond in the [Cu3S2](3+) core, whose answer is closely related to the problem of the formal oxidation state of Cu atoms. In order to contribute to the elucidation of the serious differences in the conclusions of earlier studies, we report in this study the detailed comprehensive analysis of the electronic structure of the [Cu3S2](3+) core using the methodologies that are specifically designed to address three particular aspects of the bonding in the core of the above complex, namely, the presence and/or absence of direct S-S bond, the existence and the nature of spin-spin interactions among the atoms in the core, and the formal oxidation state of Cu atoms in the core. Using such a combined approach, it was possible to conclude that the picture of bonding consistently indicates the existence of a weak direct two-center-three-electron (2c-3e) S-S bond, but at the same time, the observed lack of any significant local spin in the core of the complex is at odds with the suggested existence of antiferromagnetic coupling among the Cu and S atoms, so that the peculiarities of the bonding in the complex seem to be due to extensive delocalization of the unpaired spin in the [Cu3S2](3+) core. Finally, a scrutiny of the effective atomic hybrids and their occupations points to a predominant formal Cu(II) oxidation state, with a weak contribution of partial Cu(I) character induced mainly by the partial flow of electrons from S to Cu atoms and high delocalization of the unpaired spin in the [Cu3S2](3+) core.

A General Mechanism for the Copper- and Silver-Catalyzed Olefin Aziridination Reactions: Concomitant Involvement of the Singlet and Triplet Pathways

The olefin aziridination reactions catalyzed by copper and silver complexes bearing hydrotris(pyrazolyl)borate (Tp(x)) ligands have been investigated from a mechanistic point of view. Several mechanistic probe reactions were carried out, specifically competition experiments with p-substituted styrenes, stereospecificity of olefins, effects of the radical inhibitors, and use of a radical clock. Data from these experiments seem to be contradictory, as they do not fully support the previously reported concerted or stepwise mechanisms. But theoretical calculations have provided the reaction profiles for both the silver and copper systems with different olefins to satisfy all experimental data. A mechanistic proposal has been made on the basis of the information that we collected from experimental and theoretical studies. In all cases, the reaction starts with the formation of a metal-nitrene species that holds some radical character, and therefore the aziridination reaction proceeds through the radical mechanism. The silver-based systems however hold a minimum energy crossing point (MECP) between the triplet and closed-shell singlet surfaces, which induce the direct formation of the aziridines, and stereochemistry of the olefin is retained. In the case of copper, a radical intermediate is formed, and this intermediate constitutes the starting point for competition steps involving ring-closure (through a MECP between the open-shell singlet and triplet surfaces) or carbon-carbon bond rotation, and explains the loss of stereochemistry with a given substrate. Overall, all the initially contradictory experimental data fit in a mechanistic proposal that involves both the singlet and the triplet pathways.

Scope and Mechanistic Analysis of the Enantioselective Synthesis of Allenes by Rhodium-Catalyzed Tandem Ylide Formation/[2,3]-Sigmatropic Rearrangement between Donor/Acceptor Carbenoids and Propargylic Alcohols

Rhodium-catalyzed reactions of tertiary propargylic alcohols with methyl aryl- and styryldiazoacetates result in tandem reactions, consisting of oxonium ylide formation followed by [2,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement. This process competes favorably with the standard O-H insertion reaction of carbenoids. The resulting allenes are produced with high enantioselectivity (88-98% ee) when the reaction is catalyzed by the dirhodium tetraprolinate complex, Rh(2)(S-DOSP)(4). Kinetic resolution is possible when racemic tertiary propargylic alcohols are used as substrates. Under the kinetic resolution conditions, the allenes are formed with good diastereoselectivity and enantioselectivity (up to 6.1:1 dr, 88-93% ee), and the unreacted alcohols are enantioenriched to 65-95% ee. Computational studies reveal that the high asymmetric induction is obtained via an organized transition state involving a two-point attachment: ylide formation between the alcohol oxygen and the carbenoid and hydrogen bonding of the alcohol to a carboxylate ligand. The 2,3-sigmatropic rearrangement proceeds through initial cleavage of the O-H bond to generate an intermediate with close-lying open-shell singlet, triplet, and closed-shell singlet electronic states. This intermediate would have significant diradical character, which is consistent with the observation that the 2,3-sigmatropic rearrangement is favored with donor/acceptor carbenoids and more highly functionalized propargylic alcohols.

Heteroaryl Oxenium Ions Have Diverse and Unusual Low-Energy Electronic States

The electronic state orderings and energies of heteroaryl oxenium ions were computed using high-level CASPT2//CASSCF computations. We find that these ions have a number of diverse, low-energy configurations. Depending on the nature of the heteroaryl substituent, the lowest-energy configuration may be open-shell singlet, closed-shell singlet, or triplet, with further diversity found among the subtypes of these configurations. The 2- and 3-pyridinyl oxenium ions show small perturbations from the phenyl oxenium ion in electronic state orderings and energies, having closed-shell singlet ground states with significant gaps to an n,π* triplet state. In contrast, the 4-pyridinyl oxenium ion is computed to have a low-energy nitrenium ion-like triplet state. The pyrimidinyl oxenium ion is computed to have a near degeneracy between an open-shell singlet and triplet state, and the pyrizidinyl oxenium ion is computed to have a near-triple degeneracy between a closed-shell singlet state, an open-shell singlet state, and a triplet state. Therefore, the ground state of these latter heteroaryl oxenium ions cannot be predicted with certainty; in principle, reactivity from any of these states may be possible. These systems are of fundamental interest for probing the spin- and configuration-dependent reactivity of unusual electronic states for this important class of reactive intermediate.