Reviews held communally or in whatever fashion they so desired.Bland and his group also demanded that acculturation proceed at “a pace dictated by Indian peoples” (p. 121). Bland’s commitment to indigenous autonomy placed him at odds with HerbertWelsh (William’s uncle),the leader of the Indian Rights Association; Senator Henry L. Dawes, the author of allotment legislation in Congress; and, most bitterly, Valentine T. McGillycuddy, the federal agent to the Oglala Lakota. Bland’s resistance to allotment and coercive acculturation,unfortunately for American Indians, was just as futile in the 1880s as Parker’s opposition had been in the early 1870s. Had U.S. policy makers followed Parker’s and Bland’s recommendations, the federal government might have avoided some of the tragedies it inflicted on indigenous individuals and communities. While scholars have tended to imply that a broad consensus for allotment and acculturation existed in the latenineteenth -century United States, GenetinPilawa demonstrates that a more benign and humane path was available forAmerican policy makers. He laments that the two articulate advocates for the alternative track were unable to forestall those bent on expropriation and coerced assimilation. Allotment was the last major step in the decimation of the indigenous land base in the Pacific Northwest, and advocates for acculturation doomed many Natives in the region to the horrors of boarding schools. Students interested in the histories of Native nations and confederated tribes in Oregon and the Northwest will appreciate Genetin-Pilawa’s careful description of the political rivalries that raged before the federal government chose to pursue those devastating policies. It is worth noting that the author also includes brief discussions of the part that the Modoc War and Native rights advocate John Beeson played in this tragedy. Tim Alan Garrison Portland State University AS RUGGED AS THE TERRAIN: CCC “BOYS,” FEDERAL CONVICTS, AND WORLD WAR II ALIEN INTERNEES WRESTLE WITH A MOUNTAIN WILDERNESS by Priscilla Wegars foreword by Dick Hendricks Caxton Press, Caldwell, Idaho, in association with the Asian American Comparative Collection, University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho, 2013. Illustrations, photographs, maps, tables, notes, index. 394 pages. $21.95 paper. In a foreword to As Rugged as the Terrain, Dick Hendricks of the Federal Bureau of Prisons introduces readers to the isolated Lochsa River region,where he and his family lived from 1935 to 1937. Located in the Bitterroot Mountain range that separates north central Idaho from southeastern Montana, a site that first housed Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) “boys” and then various prisoners, became a selfcontained community, its residents laboring slowly and intermittently on the Lewis-Clark Highway across Lolo Pass. In the first chapter, Priscilla Wegars focuses on the temporary CCC Camp F-38 on the Lochsa River,followed by three chapters about the federal Lochsa Prison Camp in the same locale from 1935 to 1943. Those chapters set the context for road building, document facilities construction, and highlight the work itself,providing insight into the social setting of a prison camp that incarcerated people from various racial,ethnic, regional, and social backgrounds. The book’s appendices relate exclusively to this segment of the book, including two escapees’ interviews, a list of employees, and a list of prisoners that largely documents racial and ethnic background .Those chapters could have easily stood alone,making a fine monograph focusing on a broader history of federal and regional prisons in the region during the Great Depression. The next segment focuses on the Kooskia Internment Camp located at the site from 1943 to 1945. These four chapters distinguish American War Relocation (concentration) OHQ vol. 115, no. 4 camps such as Minidoka from alien resident and non-resident internment at places, such as Kooskia and Fort Missoula, where the United States also held Germans and Italians. Wegars thus broadens the World War II story humanely and usefully.In the final chapter,the author explores the aftermath of prison camp experiences, documents institutional shifts in management, and brings readers up-to-date on historical investigations. Wegars’s stated goal is for As Rugged as the Terrain to serve as a “prequel” by incorporating material that did not fit in her 2010 book Imprisoned in Paradise, about Japanese alien internment at the site. Although...
Read full abstract