Native Lipid Environment Research Articles

Membrane Solubilization by Diisobutylene-Maleic Acid (DIBMA) Copolymers and Characterization of the Resulting Native Nanodiscs

Amphipathic copolymers such as styrene-maleic acid (SMA) [1,2] and more recently diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA) [3] are gaining attention due to their ability to spontaneously solubilize lipid bilayers into discoidal nanoparticles. As such they are convenient tools to isolate and study membrane proteins within their native lipid environment. For SMA copolymers it has been shown that average length and composition of the copolymers are important parameters in determining the efficiency of solubilization and properties of the resulting nanodiscs.

Mass spectrometry of membrane protein complexes.

Membrane proteins are key players in the cell. Due to their hydrophobic nature they require solubilising agents such as detergents or membrane mimetics during purification and, consequently, are challenging targets in structural biology. In addition, their natural lipid environment is crucial for their structure and function further hampering their analysis. Alternative approaches are therefore required when the analysis by conventional techniques proves difficult. In this review, we highlight the broad application of mass spectrometry (MS) for the characterisation of membrane proteins and their interactions with lipids. We show that MS unambiguously identifies the protein and lipid components of membrane protein complexes, unravels their three-dimensional arrangements and further provides clues of protein-lipid interactions.

Single Liposome Measurements for the Study of Proton-Pumping Membrane Enzymes Using Electrochemistry and Fluorescent Microscopy.

Proton-pumping enzymes of electron transfer chains couple redox reactions to proton translocation across the membrane, creating a proton-motive force used for ATP production. The amphiphilic nature of membrane proteins requires particular attention to their handling, and reconstitution into the natural lipid environment is indispensable when studying membrane transport processes like proton translocation. Here, we detail a method that has been used for the investigation of the proton-pumping mechanism of membrane redox enzymes, taking cytochrome bo3 from Escherichia coli as an example. A combination of electrochemistry and fluorescence microscopy is used to control the redox state of the quinone pool and monitor pH changes in the lumen. Due to the spatial resolution of fluorescent microscopy, hundreds of liposomes can be measured simultaneously while the enzyme content can be scaled down to a single enzyme or transporter per liposome. The respective single enzyme analysis can reveal patterns in the enzyme functional dynamics that might be otherwise hidden by the behavior of the whole population. We include a description of a script for automated image analysis.

Phospholipid Headgroups Govern Emergent Bending Energy of Membranes with Implications for Lipid-Protein Interactions

Activities of integral membrane proteins are strongly affected by lipid molecular properties in the membrane bilayer [1]. Thermal motions in liquid-crystalline membranes modulate nuclear magnetic relaxation giving a connection to membrane mechanical properties through the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Application of solid-state NMR methods uniquely investigates lipid membranes in terms of both structure and dynamics as they emerge from atomistic-level interactions. Here we employed solid-state 2H NMR spectroscopy [2] and relaxometry [3] to investigate how lipid headgroups influence the properties of 1,2-diperdeuteriopalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DPPE-d62) and 1,2-diperdeuteriopalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC-d62) and their 1:1 mixtures in the liquid-disordered (ld or La) phase. Segmental order parameters (SCD) for DPPE-d62 are greater than DPPC-d62 indicating a smaller area per lipid and greater bilayer thickness. Mixtures of DPPC/DPPE (1:1) with one component deuterated showed nearly identical SCD values, regardless of the lipid species deuterated. Our results suggest SCD is determined by packing of the headgroups and is averaged over the entire system. Additional relaxation studies of the two perdeuterated lipids showed differences in their dynamics. The spin-lattice (R1Z) relaxation rates as a function of SCD2 implied collective mesoscopic dynamics and higher stiffness for DPPE-d62 membranes than for DPPC-d62 at the same temperatures [3]. In the mixtures of DPPE and DPPC the acyl chain dynamics are the same regardless of the associated headgroup and showed intermediate bending elasticities. Variation of both average and dynamic properties with phospholipid headgroup ratio suggests that membrane properties are modulated by the headgroup composition. Solid-state NMR relaxometry thus probes bending energies of biomembranes via mesoscopic dynamics that affect membrane protein function in the natural lipid environment. [1] M.F. Brown (2017) Annu. Rev. Biophys. 46, 379. [2] T.R. Molugu et al. (2017) Chem.Rev. 117, 12087. [3] T.R. Molugu et al. (2016) Chem.Phys.Lipids 199, 39.

Cysteine-ethylation of tissue-extracted membrane proteins as a tool to detect conformational states by solid-state NMR spectroscopy.

Solid-state NMR (ssNMR) is an ideal tool to study structure and dynamics of membrane proteins in their native lipid environment. In principle, ssNMR has no size limitations. However, this feature is rarely exploited as large membrane proteins display severe resonance overlap. In addition, dismal yields from recombinant bacterial expression systems limit severely spectroscopic characterization of membrane proteins. For very large mammalian membrane proteins, extraction from the original organism remains the most viable approach. In this case, NMR-observable nuclei must be introduced post-translationally, but the approaches developed so far are rather scarce. Here, we detail the synthesis and engineering of a reactive 13C-ethylmethanethiosulfonate (13C-EMTS) reagent for the post-translational alkylation of cysteine sidechains of a 110kDa sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase (SERCA) extracted from rabbit skeletal muscle tissue. When reconstituted into liposomes, it is possible to resolve the resonances of the engineered ethyl groups by magic-angle spinning (MAS) 2D [13C,13C]-DARR experiments. Notably, the ethyl-group modification does not perturb the function of SERCA, yielding well-resolved 13C-13C fingerprints that are used to image its structural states in the catalytic cycle and filtering out overwhelming naturally-abundant 13C nuclei signals arising from the enzyme and lipids. We anticipate that this approach will be used together with 19F NMR to monitor conformational transitions of enzymes and proteins that are difficult to express recombinantly.

Frontispiece: Structural Mass Spectrometry of Membrane Proteins within Their Native Lipid Environments

Frontispiece: Structural Mass Spectrometry of Membrane Proteins within Their Native Lipid Environments

Isolating and Incorporating Light-Harvesting Antennas from Diatom Cyclotella Meneghiniana in Liposomes with Thylakoid Lipids.

The photosynthetic performance of plants, algae and diatoms strongly depends on the fast and efficient regulation of the light harvesting and energy transfer processes in the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts. The light harvesting antenna of diatoms, the so called fucoxanthin chlorophyll a/c binding proteins (FCP), are required for the light absorption and efficient transfer to the photosynthetic reaction centers as well as for photo-protection from excessive light. The switch between these two functions is a long-standing matter of research. Many of these studies have been carried out with FCP in detergent micelles. For interaction studies, the detergents have been removed, which led to an unspecific aggregation of FCP complexes. In this approach, it is hard to discriminate between artifacts and physiologically relevant data. Hence, more valuable information about FCP and other membrane bound light harvesting complexes can be obtained by studying protein-protein interactions, energy transfer and other spectroscopic features if they are embedded in their native lipid environment. The main advantage is that liposomes have a defined size and a defined lipid/protein ratio by which the extent of FCP clustering is controlled. Further, changes in the pH and ion composition that regulate light harvesting in vivo can easily be simulated. In comparison to the thylakoid membrane, the liposomes are more homogenous and less complex, which makes it easier to obtain and understand spectroscopic data. The protocol describes the procedure of FCP isolation and purification, liposome preparation, and incorporation of FCP into liposomes with natural lipid composition. Results from a typical application are given and discussed.

The use of styrene-maleic acid copolymer (SMA) for studies on T cell membrane rafts

An emerging alternative to the use of detergents in biochemical studies on membrane proteins is apparently the use styrene-maleic acid (SMA) amphipathic copolymers. These cut the membrane into nanodiscs (SMA-lipid particles, SMALPs), which contain membrane proteins possibly surrounded by their native lipid environment. We examined this approach for studies on several types of T cell membrane proteins, previously defined as raft or non-raft associated, to see whether the properties of the raft derived SMALPs differ from non-raft SMALPs. Our results indicate that two types of raft proteins, GPI-anchored proteins and two Src family kinases, are markedly present in membrane fragments much larger (>250 nm) than those containing non-raft proteins (<20 nm). Lipid probes sensitive to membrane fluidity (membrane order) indicate that the lipid environment in the large SMALPs is less fluid (more ordered) than in the small ones which may indicate the presence of a more ordered lipid Lo phase which is characteristic of membrane rafts. Also the lipid composition of the small vs. large SMALPs is markedly different – the large ones are enriched in cholesterol and lipids containing saturated fatty acids. In addition, we confirm that T cell membrane proteins present in SMALPs can be readily immunoisolated. Our results support the use of SMA as a potentially better (less artifact prone) alternative to detergents for studies on membrane proteins and their complexes, including membrane rafts.

Structural Mass Spectrometry of Membrane Proteins within Their Native Lipid Environments.

Mass spectrometry has emerged as an important structural biology tool for understanding membrane protein structure, function, and dynamics. Generally, structural mass spectrometry of membrane proteins has been performed on purified or reconstituted systems which lack the native lipid membrane and cellular environments. However, there has been progress in the use and adaptations of these methods for probing membrane proteins within increasingly more native contexts. In this Concept article the use and utility of structural mass spectrometry techniques for studying membrane proteins within native environments are highlighted.

Molecular Mechanism of Lipid Nanodisk Formation by Styrene-Maleic Acid Copolymers

Experimental characterization of membrane proteins often requires solubilization. A recent approach is to use styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers to isolate membrane proteins in nanometer-sized membrane disks, or so-called SMA lipid particles (SMALPs). The approach has the advantage of allowing direct extraction of proteins, keeping their native lipid environment. Despite the growing popularity of using SMALPs, the molecular mechanism behind the process remains poorly understood. Here, we unravel the molecular details of the nanodisk formation by using coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations. We show how SMA copolymers bind to the lipid bilayer interface, driven by the hydrophobic effect. Due to the concerted action of multiple adsorbed copolymers, large membrane defects appear, including small, water-filled pores. The copolymers can stabilize the rim of these pores, leading to pore growth and membrane disruption. Although complete solubilization is not seen on the timescale of our simulations, self-assembly experiments show that small nanodisks are the thermodynamically preferred end state. Our findings shed light on the mechanism of SMALP formation and on their molecular structure. This can be an important step toward the design of optimized extraction tools for membrane protein research.

Mass Spectrometry of Bacterial Outer Membrane Enzymes within the Native Lipid Environment

Lipid complexity of bacterial membranes and the dynamic interaction of lipophilic substrates with membrane‐embedded enzymes reflect a demand for a robust detection approach that unravels the local lipids and hydrophobic substrates/products either bound or within the milieu of membrane enzymes. In this study, we used styrene maleic acid lipid particle (SMALP) nanodiscs and electrospray ionization‐ion mobility spectrometry–mass spectrometry (ESI‐IMS) mass spectrometry to address the stability of lipid‐bound states of two bacterial β‐barrel enzymes.We overexpressed and purified different oligomeric states of two model β‐barrel enzymes with their co‐associated lipids (i.e. enzyme substrates/products) from the outer membrane of E.coli using various polymer formulations. We further examined the stability of the intact lipid‐protein nanodiscs in solution as well as in the gas phase. Our results, thus far, has demonstrated the higher efficacy of the native nanodiscs over conventional detergents in isolating lipid populations bound to the enzymes, also an improved thermal stability of the resulting β‐barrel complexes in solution. We have, interestingly, observed that some polymers are more compatible with the required conditions in mass spectrometry hence overcoming limitations (e.g. low pH which is known as destabilizing factor for the original SMALP nanodiscs) in the structural analysis of lipid‐bound states of membrane proteins in the gas phase.This abstract is from the Experimental Biology 2018 Meeting. There is no full text article associated with this abstract published in The FASEB Journal.

Purification of membrane proteins free from conventional detergents: SMA, new polymers, new opportunities and new insights.

Membrane proteins remain a somewhat enigmatic group of biomolecules. On the one hand they mediate some of the most important processes in biology with molecular mechanisms that are often elegantly complex. On the other hand they are exceptionally challenging to produce, making studies of membrane protein structure and function among the most difficult projects undertaken by biochemists. The central issue with studies of a membrane protein has been the need to extract them from their native lipid environment before purification and production of a homogenous sample. Historical approaches have utilized detergent solubilisation but these often lead to a sample with low activity and stability. In the past 15 years a new approach that focuses on preserving the local lipid environment surrounding the membrane proteins has been developed. The latest, and perhaps most complete, incarnation of this method has been the use of polymers based on styrene maleic acid (SMA) to stabilise nanoscale discs of lipid that contain membrane proteins. In this review we examine the range of SMA-related polymers that have now been shown to have utility in the production of membrane proteins. We discuss the differences between the polymers and attempt to discover rules and trends that explain their behavior.

The yin and yang of solubilization and stabilization for wild-type and full-length membrane protein.

Membrane proteins (MP) are stable in their native lipid environment. To enable structural and functional investigations, MP need to be extracted from the membrane. This is a critical step that represents the main obstacle for MP biochemistry and structural biology. General guidelines and rules for membrane protein solubilization remain difficult to establish. This review aims to provide the reader with a comprehensive overview of the general concepts of MP solubilization and stabilization as well as recent advances in detergents innovation. Understanding how solubilization and stabilization are intimately linked is key to facilitate MP isolation toward fundamental structural and functional research as well as drug discovery applications. How to manage the tour de force of destabilizing the lipid bilayer and stabilizing MP at the same time is the holy grail of successful isolation and investigation of such a delicate and fascinating class of proteins.

Affinity Purification and Single-Molecule Analysis of Integral Membrane Proteins from Crude Cell-Membrane Preparations.

The function of integral membrane proteins is critically dependent on their naturally surrounding lipid membrane. Detergent-solubilized and purified membrane proteins are therefore often reconstituted into cell-membrane mimics and analyzed for their function with single-molecule microscopy. Expansion of this approach toward a broad range of pharmaceutically interesting drug targets and biomarkers however remains hampered by the fact that these proteins have low expression levels, and that detergent solubilization and reconstitution often cause protein conformational changes and loss of membrane-specific cofactors, which may impair protein function. To overcome this limitation, we here demonstrate how antibody-modified nanoparticles can be used to achieve affinity purification and enrichment of selected integral membrane proteins directly from cell membrane preparations. Nanoparticles were first bound to the ectodomain of β-secretase 1 (BACE1) contained in cell-derived membrane vesicles. In a subsequent step, these were merged into a continuous supported membrane in a microfluidic channel. Through the extended nanoparticle tag, a weak (∼fN) hydrodynamic force could be applied, inducing directed in-membrane movement of targeted BACE1 exclusively. This enabled selective thousand-fold enrichment of the targeted membrane protein while preserving a natural lipid environment. In addition, nanoparticle-targeting also enabled simultaneous tracking analysis of each individual manipulated protein, revealing how their mobility changed when moved from one lipid environment to another. We therefore believe this approach will be particularly useful for separation in-line with single-molecule analysis, eventually opening up for membrane-protein sorting devices analogous to fluorescence-activated cell sorting.

RMCE-based insect cell platform to produce membrane proteins captured on HIV-1 Gag virus-like particles.

Conformationally complex membrane proteins (MPs) are therapeutic targets in many diseases, but drug discovery has been slowed down by the lack of efficient production tools. Co-expression of MPs with matrix proteins from enveloped viruses is a promising approach to obtain correctly folded proteins at the surface of virus-like particles (VLPs), preserving their native lipidic environment. Here, we implemented a site-specific recombinase-mediated cassette exchange (RMCE) strategy to establish a reusable HIV-1 Gag-expressing insect cell line for fast production of target MPs on the surface of Gag-VLPs. The Sf9 cell line was initially tagged with a Gag-GFP-expressing cassette incorporating two flipase recognition target sites (FRTs), one within the fusion linker of Gag-GFP. The GFP cassette was afterwards replaced by a Cherry cassette via flipase (Flp) recombination. The fusion of Gag to fluorescent proteins enabled high-throughput screening of cells with higher Gag expression and Flp-mediated cassette exchange ability, while keeping the functionality of the VLP scaffold unaltered. The best cell clone was then Flp-recombinated to produce Gag-VLPs decorated with a human β2-adrenergic receptor (β2AR). Release of a fluorescently labeled β2AR into the culture supernatant was confirmed by immunoblotting, and its co-localization with Gag-VLPs was visualized by confocal microscopy. Furthermore, the differential avidity of β2AR-dsplaying Gag-VLPs versus "naked" Gag-VLPs to an anti-β2AR antibody measured by ELISA corroborated the presence of β2AR at the surface of the Gag-VLPs. In conclusion, this novel insect cell line represents a valuable platform for fast production of MPs in their native conformation, which can accelerate small-molecule and antibody drug discovery programs.

Interrogating Membrane Protein Conformational Dynamics within Native Lipid Compositions

AbstractThe interplay between membrane proteins and the lipids of the membrane is important for cellular function, however, tools enabling the interrogation of protein dynamics within native lipid environments are scarce and often invasive. We show that the styrene–maleic acid lipid particle (SMALP) technology can be coupled with hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) to investigate membrane protein conformational dynamics within native lipid bilayers. We demonstrate changes in accessibility and dynamics of the rhomboid protease GlpG, captured within three different native lipid compositions, and identify protein regions sensitive to changes in the native lipid environment. Our results illuminate the value of this approach for distinguishing the putative role(s) of the native lipid composition in modulating membrane protein conformational dynamics.

Interrogating Membrane Protein Conformational Dynamics within Native Lipid Compositions.

The interplay between membrane proteins and the lipids of the membrane is important for cellular function, however, tools enabling the interrogation of protein dynamics within native lipid environments are scarce and often invasive. We show that the styrene-maleic acid lipid particle (SMALP) technology can be coupled with hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to investigate membrane protein conformational dynamics within native lipid bilayers. We demonstrate changes in accessibility and dynamics of the rhomboid protease GlpG, captured within three different native lipid compositions, and identify protein regions sensitive to changes in the native lipid environment. Our results illuminate the value of this approach for distinguishing the putative role(s) of the native lipid composition in modulating membrane protein conformational dynamics.

Controlling Styrene Maleic Acid Lipid Particles through RAFT.

The ability of styrene maleic acid copolymers to dissolve lipid membranes into nanosized lipid particles is a facile method of obtaining membrane proteins in solubilized lipid discs while conserving part of their native lipid environment. While the currently used copolymers can readily extract membrane proteins in native nanodiscs, their highly disperse composition is likely to influence the dispersity of the discs as well as the extraction efficiency. In this study, reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer was used to control the polymer architecture and dispersity of molecular weights with a high-precision. Based on Monte Carlo simulations of the polymerizations, the monomer composition was predicted and allowed a structure-function analysis of the polymer architecture, in relation to their ability to assemble into lipid nanoparticles. We show that a higher degree of control of the polymer architecture generates more homogeneous samples. We hypothesize that low dispersity copolymers, with control of polymer architecture are an ideal framework for the rational design of polymers for customized isolation and characterization of integral membrane proteins in native lipid bilayer systems.

Bioinspired, Size-Tunable Self-Assembly of Polymer-Lipid Bilayer Nanodiscs.

Polymer-based nanodiscs are valuable tools in biomedical research that can offer a detergent-free solubilization of membrane proteins maintaining their native lipid environment. Herein, we introduce a novel ca. 1.6 kDa SMA-based polymer with styrene:maleic acid moieties that can form nanodiscs containing a planar lipid bilayer which are useful to reconstitute membrane proteins for structural and functional studies. The physicochemical properties and the mechanism of formation of polymer-based nanodiscs are characterized by light scattering, NMR, FT-IR, and TEM. A remarkable feature is that nanodiscs of different sizes, from nanometer to sub-micrometer diameter, can be produced by varying the lipid-to-polymer ratio. The small-size nanodiscs (up to ca. 30 nm diameter) can be used for solution NMR spectroscopy studies whereas the magnetic-alignment of macro-nanodiscs (diameter of > ca. 40 nm) can be exploited for solid-state NMR studies on membrane proteins.

Bioinspired, Size‐Tunable Self‐Assembly of Polymer–Lipid Bilayer Nanodiscs

AbstractPolymer‐based nanodiscs are valuable tools in biomedical research that can offer a detergent‐free solubilization of membrane proteins maintaining their native lipid environment. Herein, we introduce a novel ca. 1.6 kDa SMA‐based polymer with styrene:maleic acid moieties that can form nanodiscs containing a planar lipid bilayer which are useful to reconstitute membrane proteins for structural and functional studies. The physicochemical properties and the mechanism of formation of polymer‐based nanodiscs are characterized by light scattering, NMR, FT‐IR, and TEM. A remarkable feature is that nanodiscs of different sizes, from nanometer to sub‐micrometer diameter, can be produced by varying the lipid‐to‐polymer ratio. The small‐size nanodiscs (up to ca. 30 nm diameter) can be used for solution NMR spectroscopy studies whereas the magnetic‐alignment of macro‐nanodiscs (diameter of &gt; ca. 40 nm) can be exploited for solid‐state NMR studies on membrane proteins.