Ideologies about languages and countries are hard to shake, even in a multinational, multilingual setting like the National Hockey League (NHL) and the journalists who report on it. Despite its historical roots in Montréal and the dominance of Canadian and European players, the lingua franca of the NHL is English. In this work, we used qualitative analyses to examine players’, journalists’, and coaches’ attitudes toward languages other than English used on the ice. Across all groups, we found that Russian speakers were most likely to be assessed negatively, from being taciturn and unwilling to be interviewed (Frederickson, 2023) to being unlikely to speak good English (Keefe, 2023). Additionally, English-speaking players were more likely to associate positive sentiments with native North American English, Swedish, and Finnish speakers, but negative sentiments about Canadian French speakers and players from eastern European countries. Players and coaches also tended to be split on whether it was acceptable for other languages to be spoken in the locker room and on the ice. This work points to a fragmented in-group view of the acceptable language to use in professional hockey.