Milano Criteria Research Articles

Surveillance for hepatocellular carcinoma with a 3-months interval in "extremely high-risk" patients does not further improve survival.

An enhanced surveillance schedule has been proposed for cirrhotics with viral etiology, who are considered at extremely high-risk of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). We compared the 3- and 6-months surveillance interval, evaluating cancer stage at diagnosis and patient survival. Data of 777 HBV and HCV cirrhotic patients with HCC diagnosed under a 3-months (n=109, 3MS group) or a 6-months (n=668, 6MS group) surveillance were retrieved from the Italian Liver Cancer database. Survival in the 3MS group was considered as observed and adjusted for lead-time bias, and survival analysis was repeated after a propensity score matching. The 3-months surveillance interval neither reduced the share of patients diagnosed outside the Milano criteria, nor increased their probability to receive curative treatments. The median survival of 6MS patients (55.0 months [45.9-64.0]) was not significantly different from the observed (47.0 months [35.0-58.9]; p=0.43) and adjusted (44.9 months [33.4-56.4]; p=0.30) survival of 3MS patients. A propensity score analysis confirmed the absence of a survival advantage for 3MS patients. A tightening of surveillance schedule does not increase the diagnosis of early-stage tumors, the feasibility of curative treatments and the survival. Therefore, we should maintain the 6-months interval in the surveillance of viral cirrhotics.

AFP at transplant is associated with a higher risk of HCC recurrence after liver transplantation for patients meeting Milano criteria

Introduction: Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) recurrence rates after liver transplantation (LT) range between 8 and 20%. Elevated alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) levels at transplant can predict post-transplant HCC recurrence, however a clear cut-off value is needed in order to identify patients at higher risk, aiming at improving surveillance program after LT.

The changing scenario of hepatocellular carcinoma over the last two decades in Italy

This study investigates whether the aetiologic changes in liver disease and the improved management of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) have modified the clinical scenario of this tumour over the last 20 years in Italy. Retrospective study based on the analysis of the ITA.LI.CA (Italian Liver Cancer) database including 3027 HCC patients managed in 11 centres. Patients were divided into 3 groups according to the period of HCC diagnosis: 1987-1996 (year of the "Milano criteria" publication), 1997-2001 (year of release of the EASL guidelines for HCC), and 2002-2008. The significant changes were: (1) progressive patient ageing; (2) increasing prevalence of HCV infection until 2001, with a subsequent decrease, when the alcoholic aetiology increased; (3) liver function improvement, until 2001; (4) increasing "incidental" at the expense of "symptomatic" diagnoses, until 2001; (5) unchanged prevalence of tumours diagnosed during surveillance (around 50%), with an increasing use of the 6-month schedule; (6) favourable HCC "stage migration", until 2001; (7) increasing use of percutaneous ablation; (8) improving survival, until 2001. Over the last 20 years, several aetiologic and clinical features regarding HCC have changed. The survival improvement observed until 2001 was due to an increasing number of tumours diagnosed in early stages and in a background of compensated cirrhosis, and a growing and better use of locoregional treatments. However, the prevalence of early cancers and survival did not increase further in the last years, a result inciting national policies aimed at implementing surveillance programmes for at risk patients.

Abstract No. 190: Chemoembolization Downstaging of Hepatocellular Carcinoma for Liver Transplantation

The Milano criteria (MC) have become widely accepted guidelines for orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) candidacy in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). We evaluated the tumor response and post-OLT outcomes of patients who underwent chemoembolization either to maintain candidacy within MC or to downstage advanced disease to fall within the MC.

Hepatocellular Carcinoma in Patients With Cryptogenic Cirrhosis

Patients with cryptogenic cirrhosis (CC) can develop hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), although the clinical characteristics of HCC in these patients have not been completely defined. We aimed to characterize the clinical features of patients diagnosed with HCC after CC during a 15-year period (1992-2006). The clinical characteristics of 45 consecutive CC patients with HCC were analyzed, along with modality of diagnosis, tumor stage, treatment, survival, and causes of death. Data were compared with those of 426 consecutive patients with HCC and only hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection, diagnosed during the same period at the Italian Liver Cancer group centers. HCC patients with CC had similar impairments in liver function as patients with HCV infection (Child-Pugh class A: 53% vs 65%; P = .141). However, the HCC patients with CC had lower aminotransferase levels (P < .001) and higher platelet counts (P < .001). HCC was significantly less likely to be diagnosed during surveillance in CC patients (29% vs 64%; P < .0001). Patients with CC had a significantly greater prevalence of advanced HCC stage, according to Milano criteria (69% vs 41%; P < .0005), larger HCC size (4.9 vs 3.0 cm; P = .0001), lower amenability to any treatment (27% vs 42%; P = .036), and shorter survival times (P = .009, log-rank test) compared with HCV patients. Causes of death were similar in the 2 groups. Compared with HCV patients, HCC in CC patients often is diagnosed at an advanced stage, probably owing to lack of surveillance; this leads to limited treatment options and shorter survival times.

Standards und neue Aspekte der Diagnostik und Therapie des hepatozellulären Karzinoms

Das hepatozellulare Karzinom (HCC) ist trotz einer Vielzahl von Behandlungsoptionen noch immer mit einer sehr hohen Mortalitat assoziiert. Wegen der haufigen Entstehung in einer zirrhotischen Leber ist der mogliche Therapieerfolg durch die eingeschrankte Lebenserwartung der Grunderkrankung limitiert. Wie bei kaum einer anderen Tumorentitat bestimmt die verbleibende Leberfunktion die Behandlungsmodalitaten. Die vor allem im europaischen Raum durch die BCLC-Klassifikation gepragte Standardtherapie der einzelnen HCC-Stadien wird durch neue Studien immer wieder auf den Prufstand gestellt. Aktuelle Arbeiten zur Resektion multipler Herde, selbst bei Vorliegen einer portalen Hypertonie, und die lokale Therapie immer groserer HCCs mittels multipolarer Radiofrequenzablation mussen hinsichtlich ihrer Ubertragbarkeit in die klinische Routine kritisch uberpruft werden. Die Ausdehnung der Milan-Kriterien als Standard zur Auswahl von Patienten zur Lebertransplantation ist strittig. Aufgrund der Organknappheit und der damit verbundenen Wartezeit sind „bridging-“ und „downstaging“-Ansatze von HCC-Patienten auf der Warteliste von groserer Bedeutung. Das Verhalten eines HCC unter Chemoembolisation als Surrogatmarker der biologischen Aktivitat konnte in Zukunft zur Stratifizierung des HCC herangezogen werden. Mit der Zulassung von Sorafenib aufgrund der Uberlebensverlangerung beim fortgeschrittenen HCC etabliert sich die „targeted therapy“ nun auch beim HCC. Eine Vielzahl weiterer Substanzen wird ihren Stellenwert in Zukunft zeigen. In dieser Ubersichtsarbeit werden die stadiengerechte Standardtherapie und neue Entwicklungen der interventionellen, chirurgischen und pharmakologischen Therapie des HCC diskutiert.

Treatment before Liver Transplantation for HCC

Liver transplantation (LT) which is currently an established therapy for sma1l, early stage hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in patients with cirrhosis requires in most cases long waiting period. Tumor development during the waiting period may be associated with vascular invasion which is a strong factor of postoperative recurrence. Therefore, local treatment of the tumor including trans-arterial chemoembolization (TACE), percutaneous radiofrequency (RF) or partial liver resection can be used before transplantation. In the present paper we reviewed the efficacy of these treatments prior to LT. Although, TACE induced complete tumor necrosis in some patients there is no convincing arguments showing that this treatment reduces the rate of drop out before LT, nor improves the survival after LT. Although, RF can induce complete necrosis in the majority of small tumors (<2.5 cm), there is no data demonstrating that this treatment reduce the rate of drop out before LT, nor improves the survival after LT. It has been showed that both short and long term survival after LT was not compromised by previous partial liver resection of HCC. However, there is no data demonstrating that liver resection before LT, which can be used either as a bridge treatment or as a primary treatment, improves the survival after LT. The current data suggest that there is no role for pre-transplant therapy for HCC within Milano criteria transplanted within six months. On the opposite, if the waiting time is predicted to be prolonged, the risk of tumor progression and either drop-off from the list or interval dissemination with post-transplant tumor recurrence is recognized. In this setting, bridge therapy can reduce that risk but its efficacy has to be determined.

The contribution of transplantation to the treatment of liver tumors in children

Major progress has been achieved during the last decades in the treatment of malignant liver tumors in children, both in chemotherapy and surgical management. Chemosensitivity varies between tumor types, and radical resection remains essential to effect a cure. In tumors extensively involving a normal liver, in a diffuse or multifocal manner, radical resection cannot be accomplished with a partial hepatectomy. This has been the case for some instances of advanced hepatoblastoma and epithelioid hemangioendothelioma. In hepatoblastoma, current experience shows that results of primary liver transplantation with neoadjuvant chemotherapy are excellent with around an 80% 5-to-10-year disease-free survival rate. Epithelioid hemangioendothelioma is very rarely seen in children and may have a more malignant behavior than in adult patients, and liver transplantation may not be the best management option. In nonresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) developed on an otherwise normal liver, the results of liver transplantation are similarly poor to those obtained in adult patients, except in a few highly selected series fulfilling the Milano criteria. The experience with HCC is still very scarce in children. Incidental HCC associated with chronic liver disease does not seem to impact posttransplant survival. When they are symptomatic, however, indications for transplantation should be very selective regarding tumor size, multi-focality, vascular invasion and distant metastases.

TACE: Therapie des HCC vor Lebertransplantation - Erfahrungen

Analysis of the course of disease in patients with histologically proven HCC before and after orthotopic liver transplantation (LTx) who received transarterial chemoembolization (TACE). Thirty-five of a total collective of 363 patients with histologically proven HCC underwent LTx. Before LTx, all patients were treated with sequential TACE. According to treatment pattern, TACE should be performed every 6 weeks, using a suspension consisting of max. 10 mg Mitomycin C as well as 10 - 30 ml iodized oil (Lipiodol). Patients were classified according to the Milano criteria. Criteria were called exceeded if the tumor size was > 5 cm and/or > 3 tumors larger than 3 cm were found. Therapy success and liver function were examined by means of spiral CT and laboratory controls. Investigation parameters included the number of tumor knots as well as the maximum tumor size. Additionally, the Lipiodol accumulation, the patency of the portal vein and the occurrence of complications were checked. Altogether, 184 TACE procedures were accomplished (5.3 +/- 3.3, range 1 - 14). The waiting period up to the transplantation amounted to 366 +/- 255 days (range 44 - 1137). The average number of tumor knots for each patient was 3.1 +/- 2.2 before and 2.9 +/- 2.2 after TACE (p = 0.887). The average tumor size was 4.2 +/- 2.5 before and 2.8 +/- 1.4 after TACE. The Milano criteria to LTx crossed 17/35 patients. Patients with exceeded Milan criteria showed a highly significant size reduction of the tumor after TACE (p = 0.001); in 9/17 cases the transplantation criteria were secondarily fulfilled through downstaging. A successful LTx was accomplished in 35/35 cases. Follow up after LTx was 769 +/- 509 days. The tumor recurrence in patients with exceeded vs. fulfilled transplantation criteria was 11.1 % vs. 11.8 % (p = 0.99). The recurrence free survival was 93.3 %, 82.5 % and 82.5 % at 1, 3 and 5 years, respectively. There were no relevant differences between patients with exceeded vs. fulfilled transplantation criteria (p = 0.99). The sequential TACE is an effective method for the therapy of the HCC before LTx in selected patients. A relevant downsizing could be achieved by TACE in patients with advanced HCC. Patients with larger tumors showed a significantly stronger size reduction after TACE. The recurrence rate and the survival rate for patients with advanced or small tumors do not differ.

Underestimation of the influence of satellite nodules as a risk factor for post-transplantation recurrence in patients with small hepatocellular carcinoma.

Liver transplantation offers good results in patients with small hepatocellular carcinoma. However, 3 to 15% of patients still have recurrence, suggesting that factors other than the size and number of nodules are implicated. The aim of our study was to identify predictive factors of recurrence in patients with small hepatocellular carcinoma. Seventy consecutive patients fulfilling Milano criteria and who were transplanted for hepatocellular carcinoma were studied. Forty-six patients had pretransplantation adjuvant local therapy. The size and number of tumors, the clinical and biological characteristics of the patients were recorded before liver transplantation, and histological analysis was performed on the explanted liver. Overall survival rates at 1 and 3 years were 81% and 66%, respectively. Recurrence-free survival rates at 1 and 3 years were 80% and 65%, respectively. Seven patients had tumor recurrence with 1- and 3-year recurrence rates of 5% and 10%, respectively. Satellite nodules on the explanted liver were the only statistically significant predictor of recurrence (P=.0003). None of the patients who did not have satellite nodules had recurrence. There was a significant correlation between satellite nodules and microvascular invasion. Patients with pretransplantation adjuvant therapy had significantly more tumor necrosis, but did not have less satellite nodules. In conclusion, microscopic satellite nodules are a significant predictive factor of tumor recurrence in patients transplanted for small hepatocellular carcinoma.

Review article: liver transplantation for HCC. Treatment options on the waiting list.

The most widely adopted criteria to admit and maintain patients with HCC and cirrhosis in the waiting list for liver transplantation are the Milano criteria, consisting in the presence of a single tumour <or=5 cm in diameter or up to three tumours, none exceeding 3 cm in diameter. Since the average time to transplantation has become longer than 10-12 months in most European and American Centers, the exclusion from the list during the waiting period due to increase of the neoplasm over the established criteria is not uncommon at present. It is mandatory, therefore, to seek an effective therapeutic strategy for patients with HCC waiting for transplantation. Surgical resection and eventual subsequent salvage transplantation seems a cost-effective strategy in resectable HCC. In unresectable neoplasms both transarterial chemoembolization and percutaneous ablation techniques are currently used and one or the other are chosen according to individual applicability, limitations and specific risks. However, although positive trends were reported, no definitive evidence has been produced so far about their efficacy in increasing patient's survival and decreasing tumour recurrence rates after transplantation. Adult-to-adult living donor liver transplantation is one possible way to shorten the waiting list, but this strategy involves important ethical implications. At present it appears justified to take it into consideration only if the waiting time for cadaveric OLT is expected to exceed 7 months. A more general and definitive attempt to overcome problems related to long waiting times for patients with HCC and relatively preserved hepatic function has been introduced in the USA very recently and consists in prioritizing patients with HCC. However, the overall efficacy of this approach will be established only in some years.

Low recurrence rate of hepatocellular carcinoma after liver transplantation: better patient selection or lower immunosuppression?

Liver transplantation is currently offered to a limited number of patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) because of strict criteria introduced in the past to avoid recurrence. Immunosuppression represents a risk factor for tumor growth; the schedules of the immunosuppressant drugs have been modified through the years, aiming to reduce their dosage to the effective minimum. A series of 106 consecutive patients with HCC who underwent transplantation over a 15-year period at a single institution was retrospectively reviewed to ascertain whether tumor recurrence was influenced by the Milano criteria presently adopted in patient selection and whether the dosage of immunosuppressant agents administered was associated with tumor recurrence. Fifteen patients who died postoperatively and 9 with a follow-up of less than 1 year were excluded; presence of the Milano criteria, tumor-node-metastasis staging, and the cumulative dosage of the single immunosuppressants given at different intervals in the first postoperative year were analyzed in the remaining 82 patients. The influence of these variables on overall and recurrence-free survival was assessed statistically. The Milano criteria did not influence recurrence-free survival, which was instead associated with the cumulative dosage of cyclosporine administered in the first postoperative year (93% 5-year recurrence-free survival for patients given low dosage vs. 76% for those given high dosage; P=0.01); T3 and T4 tumors did worse than T1 and T2 tumors. Current limits to transplantation for HCC might be reassessed in view of modified patient management; immunosuppression should be minimized in these patients.