The mass transfer characteristics of porous carbon electrodes in the liquid side of a hydrogen bromine redox flow battery (H2-Br2 RFB) were investigated under compressive deformation caused by operation at elevated hydrogen pressure. Here, flow cell measurements of permeability and micro-particle image velocimetry (μPIV), alongside electrochemical measurements of capacitance and battery discharge were used to characterize changes in the liquid side electrode compression, in-plane liquid flow, accessible surface area, polarization, and mass transfer scaling brought by hydrogen pressure. We studied two electrode types with different structures, carbon paper and carbon cloth, in untreated well as heat-treated forms in the pressure range 0–8 bar H2. It was found that pressure-induced compression of the liquid side electrode increases the accessible area of untreated electrodes, with little effect on heat-treated electrodes, but decreases the electrochemical performance of the battery in all cases by increasing the ohmic resistance of the cell and decreasing the mass transfer coefficient of the porous electrode. Overall, heat treatment is shown to affect the rigidity, saturation behavior, and generalized mass transfer of paper electrodes but not of cloth electrodes. Our findings will guide the selection of electrode materials and operation parameters for the H2-Br2 RFB.