Superbase-derived deep eutectic solvents (DESs) are considered as biodegradable, low toxic, and sustainable solvents for efficient capture and conversion of carbon dioxide. However, do superbase-derived DESs have low toxicity just as reported? Herein, contradictory to the conventional thought, we find that the toxicity of superbase-derived DESs is super high. The toxicity of superbase-derived DESs in this work could be ca. 266 times that of DESs previously reported. Moreover, toxicity could be tuned by changing hydrogen bond donors, hydrogen bond acceptors, and mole ratios. The results indicate that the types of hydrogen bond donors had a paramount effect on the toxicity of DESs, and increasing the molar ratio of higher toxic components will also increase the toxicity of DESs. This work will provide possible ways to reduce the toxicity of DESs for achieving sustainable and green capture and conversion of carbon dioxide.