Over many decades, an understanding of total organic carbon (TOC) variability in various sedimentary basins has been constrained by the availability of suitable samples for geochemical analysis. Many attempts rely on selected sidewall core or cuttings samples, which do not provide a continuous lithological record of the succession. As a result, TOC variability as a response to facies evolution is often underestimated. An advancement in TOC evaluation from well logging techniques often has permitted a continuous analysis of source rock intervals, while eliminating issues associated with obtaining discrete physical samples. Geochemical and wireline geophysical logs investigation here aimed at constraining TOC variability and depositional conditions prevailing during the early Jurassic in the Tanzanian Mandawa Basin (Mbuo, Nondwa and Mihambia Formations), which to date are poorly documented. TOC was deduced from both well cuttings samples and wire log data. Depositional conditions were defined via the use of spectral Gamma-Ray (Th/U, U) logging and lithofacies data. Sediment composition and TOC from cuttings were compared to illustrate how organic matter distribution is influenced by changes in sediment type. Complex mineral composition of heterolithic facies dominated log-response, complicated log interpretation, and thus limited the effectiveness of well logging techniques to predict TOC. Cuttings data reveal three organic-rich intervals, i) at the transition of Upper Mbuo to basal Nondwa Formation with the highest TOC of 3.5 (wt%), ii) in the Nondwa Formation with a TOC of 2 (wt%), and iii) in the Mihambia Formation with a TOC of 2.8 (wt%). An inverse linear relationship between Th/U and TOC signifies relatively shallow deposition in a well-mixed water column under oxic conditions. Intervals with higher TOC imply organic matter preservation under suboxic conditions upon two marine incursions in the Mihambia and Nondwa Formations, whereas a limnic environment prevailed at the Upper Mbuo to Nondwa transition. Inverse trends in TOC versus clastic components, a positive linear relationship between TOC and carbonates, and higher amount of clastics (>57 wt%) in the Mbuo and Mihambia Formations suggest a dominantly clastic sedimentary system with relatively stable carbonate and organic matter input in proximity to the source area. We, therefore, argue that the organic rich intervals observed in the Upper Mbuo, Nondwa and Mihambia Formations were deposited during periods of higher organic productivity driven by a rise in eustatic sea level, and coincide with a decline in terrigenous input from the hinterland.