Physical touch as a teaching methodology for voice teachers is a subject that must be confronted. The issue is a timely one considering recent social movements that are shedding light on systems of power that lead to abusive practices within society. Furthermore, there is a lack of information and consensus in recently published vocal pedagogy and music education literature regarding the effectiveness of physical touch as a teaching modality. Some voice teachers feel physical touch is necessary for quickly correcting a technical problem, while others feel that physical touch is the only way to demonstrate certain technical concepts. Currently, voice pedagogy literature that advocates for the use of physical touch in a private voice lesson is predominately supported anecdotally rather than by research, and significantly lacks the perspective of the student. The field of motor learning research can be useful in informing voice pedagogy in specific areas of intersection. Additionally, when considering other factors (such as trauma and power dynamics in the voice studio), other equally viable teaching options must be considered. Given the current state of the field of voice pedagogy, it is of the opinion of the author that physical touch as a pedagogical technique in a voice lesson should be abandoned.
Read full abstract