In an era that has seen significant changes in the way we manage nonhealing venous leg ulceration, this study reports the rationale, results, and changing trends of an 18-year experience of deep vein valve reconstruction with evaluation of end points at 2, 5 and 10 years in the management of nonhealing venous leg ulcers in 228 patients. A total of 228 patients (302 limbs) undergoing deep vein reconstructions were followed up for 2 to 18 years (mean, 8 ± 2.3 years). All patients had nonhealing C6 venous leg ulcers of >3 months' duration and were offered deep venous reconstruction as a “last resort” treatment. End-points of the study were freedom from leg ulceration, vein valve patency, and competence assessed serially by physical examination and duplex scanning. Primary refluxive disease was present in 156 patients (209 limbs). External valvuloplasty was performed in 12 limbs (19 valves), and internal valvuloplasty was performed in 181 limbs (324 valves). External supports were used in 16 limbs (16 valves). Multilevel (≥2) reconstructions were performed in 126 limbs. Seventy-two patients had secondary valvular defects involving 93 limbs. Axillary-femoral vein valve transplant was performed for 49 patients (64 limbs) and Maleti Neovalve in five patients (five Limbs) respectively. Saphenofemoral venous transposition was performed in 7 patients (nine limbs), and femoral/popliteal vein ligation was carried out in 11 patients (15 limbs). At 10 years, external valvuloplasty showed ulcer healing in 16% of limbs, with maintenance of competency at only 15.7% of valve stations. Internal valvuloplasty was the most durable valve repair procedure, with actuarial leg ulcer healing rates of 67% and valve station competency of 79%. It was also noted that single-level repairs had significantly lower ulcer healing rates than multilevel repairs (P = .0018). For secondary incompetence, valve transplants had a gradual but increasing deterioration in valve patency and competency at 10 years: 46.8% and 38.3%, respectively, with 36.6% actuarial leg ulcer healing. Although the Maleti Neovalve in our hands performed well initially, all repairs thrombosed by 9 months. Even venous transpositions had no valve competency >2 years. Valvular reconstruction for refluxive disease is effective in healing venous ulcers that defy conservative management and superficial/perforator venous surgery out at 10 years. Furthermore, these procedures are useful for primary but not for secondary incompetence. Multilevel or multivalve reconstructions yield superior results to single-level repairs in medium-term follow-up. Open reconstructions for secondary incompetence may be a waste of time, with increased morbidity.
Read full abstract