The occurrence of fungi is cosmopolitan, and while some mushroom species are beneficial to human health, others can be toxic and cause illness problems. This study aimed to analyze the organoleptic, ecological, and morphological characteristics of a group of fungal specimens and identify the most significant features to develop models for fungal toxicity classification using genetic algorithms and LASSO regression. The results of the study indicated that odor, spore print color, and habitat were the most significant characteristics identified by the genetic algorithm GALGO. Meanwhile, odor, gill size, stalk shape, and twelve other features were the relevant characteristics identified by LASSO regression. The importance score of the odor variable was 99.99%, gill size obtained 73.7%, stalk shape scored 39.9%, and the remaining variables did not score higher than 18%. Logistic regression, k-nearest neighbor (KNN), and XG-Boost classification algorithms were used to develop models using the features selected by both GALGO and LASSO. The models were evaluated using sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy metrics. The models with the highest AUC values were XGBoost, with a maximum value of 0.99 using the features selected by LASSO, followed by KNN with a maximum value of 0.99. The GALGO selection resulted in a maximum AUC of 0.98 in KNN and XGBoost. The models developed in this study have the potential to aid in the accurate identification of toxic fungi, which can prevent health problems caused by their consumption.