Planktonic diatoms of the genus Planktoniella are characterized by organic extensions from the girdle. Planktoniella species are solitary, except for a colonial form that was first described as Coenobiodiscus muriformis from San Diego Bay, California. We established a culture of Planktoniella muriformis from Mazatlán, Gulf of California, in order to solve its phylogenetic affinities using molecular markers. Beyond the distinct colony morphology, P. muriformis has one marginal rimoportula and absence of mantle ribs, while two rimoportulae and numerous mantle ribs are the signature characteristics in the solitary species of the genus Planktoniella. In the SSU-, LSU rRNA and RuBisCO large subunit (rbcL) gene phylogenies, P. muriformis is nested within sequences from the paraphyletic genus Thalassiosira. The sequences are distantly related to the clade of the type species of Planktoniella, P. sol, and four other congeneric species, and the type species of Thalassiosira or any other thalassiosiroid genera, supporting consideration as an independent genus. In the rbcL gene phylogeny, the sequence of P. muriformis allies with distinct thalassiosiroid genera without bootstrap support, while in the SSU and LSU rRNA gene phylogenies it is nested with support as a sister group of two strains of T. hispida or the strain BEN02-35 identified as Thalassiosira angulata, respectively. The considerable genetic distance between these taxa and P. muriformis, and the lack of distinctive common morphological features do not support their placement in the same genus. Based on analyses of nuclear and chloroplast molecular markers, and the distinctive morphology of P. muriformis, with a unique type of colony formation unknown in any other diatom, we reinstate the genus Coenobiodiscus for P. muriformis.
Read full abstract