The author must be commended for giving another remarkable contribution to foundation engineering. Designs are almost always made assuming ideal situations, but geological and construction imperfections do exist. Especially in the case of bored piles, one must recognize that construction effects have a major influence on their stiffness. A very competent designer, using very reliable soil information and an extraordinarily precise method for predicting the bearing capacity of a pile, may, in some cases, make a not-so-reliable prediction. In other words, these very favorable conditions alone do not guarantee a successful design. The reason is that in the design phase no one knows how the pile is going to be built. The author has shown very clearly the influence of a “soft base” in the stiffness of a pile. Fig. 25 shows that for a given load, the pile with “unclean” base settles about three times more than a similar pile with a “clean” base. And it is not a 20 or 30% difference, but a 200% difference. The discusser would like to add new information on this matter. The case of a foundation for a large industrial plant will be analyzed. The foundation consisted of about 4,000 mechanically drilled bored piles, 70 cm in diameter. The soil was a compacted fill. The design specification required that after finishing the drilling procedure, the walls of the shaft should have to be cleaned by a foreman using steel brittle brushes. After that, the bases had to be cleaned and then, the pile concreted. To evaluate the influence of the “cleaning” procedure on the bearing capacity of the pile, two load tests were carried out. Although the two test piles were close to each other and within the same compacted layer, it was decided to carry out two SPTTs. The SPT-T is the traditional SPT complemented with torque measurements, Decourt and Quaresma Filho 1994 . In order to reduce the influence of soil heterogeneity on the results, the discusser required the axes of the piles to coincide exactly with the axes of the borings SPT-T . The results of the two SPT-Ts were very close to each other, so it was considered that direct comparison between the two load
Read full abstract