In this work, an experimental and kinetic modeling study has been conducted to bridge the knowledge gap pertaining to the reactivity of blends of saturated and unsaturated methyl esters at intermediate temperatures. We consider two well-known biodiesel surrogates: the saturated ester methyl butanoate and the unsaturated ester methyl crotonate. These compounds were considered due to the wealth of experimental and modeling data available in the literature for the molecules. We conducted experiments to measure ignition delay times of mixtures of methyl butanoate and methyl crotonate using a Rapid Compression Machine (RCM) across different equivalence ratios (0.5, 1.0, 1.5) and at pressures of 20 and 30 bar. Furthermore, we developed an improved kinetic model that thoroughly validates the newly obtained RCM experimental data for the blend of methyl butanoate and methyl crotonate, in addition to existing experimental studies for the individual components. Present kinetic modeling work involved the incorporation of several new reaction pathways and rates, resulting in improved predictions of combustion characteristics. This study offers insights into the various reaction pathways that influence the reactivity of the blend as well as explains the interactions between methyl butanoate and methyl crotonate based on the underlying kinetics.