The driving motive of this work is to enhance the tolerability of a flat Fresnel-lens concentrator to tracking errors, without the use of secondary optics or sophisticated, and normally costly, meticulous tracking equipment. This is achieved by optimizing the prismatic geometry of the Fresnel lens through a statistical approach that incorporates laws of light refraction and trigonometry. The proposed design produces high focal heat flux that is more suitable for thermal applications. A comparative simulation analysis was conducted for two case studies from literature, each with a different design method for the Fresnel lens. On basis of equivalent geometric concentration ratio and f-number, the flat-spot lenses, designed by this study, returned higher values of the concentration acceptance product ( $$CAP$$ ). In case #1 of a 212× cylindrical lens with an f-number of unity, an equivalent flat lens by this work almost doubled the $$CAP$$ from 0.165 to 0.34. For the design case #2 of a 559× aspheric Fresnel lens made by simple geometrical optics, a 60.7% enhanced $$CAP$$ was achieved by this work’s lens, from 0.206 to 0.331, at an f-number of 0.83.