β-amyloid42 (Aβ42) in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and orexin in narcolepsy are considered crucial biomarkers for diagnosis and therapeutic targets. Recently, orexin and Aβ cerebral dynamics have been studied in both pathologies, but how they interact with each other remains further to be known. In this study, we investigated the reliability of using the correlation between orexin-A and Aβ42 CSF levels as a candidate marker to explain the chain of events leading to narcolepsy or AD pathology. In order to test the correlation between these biomarkers, patients diagnosed with AD (n = 76), narcolepsy type 1 (NT1, n = 17), narcolepsy type 2 (NT2, n = 23) and healthy subjects (n = 91) were examined. Patients and healthy subjects underwent lumbar puncture between 8:00 and 10:00 am at the Neurology Unit of the University Hospital of Rome “Tor Vergata”. CSF levels of Aβ42, total-tau, phosphorylated-tau, and orexin-A were assessed. The results showed that CSF levels of Aβ42 were significantly lower (p < 0.001) in AD (332.28 ± 237.36 pg/mL) compared to NT1 (569.88 ± 187.00 pg/mL), NT2 (691.00 ± 292.63 pg/mL) and healthy subjects (943.68 ± 198.12 pg/mL). CSF orexin-A levels were statistically different (p < 0.001) between AD (148.01 ± 29.49 pg/mL), NT1 (45.94 ± 13.63 pg/mL), NT2 (104.92 ± 25.55 pg/mL) and healthy subjects (145.18 ± 27.01 pg/mL). Moderate-severe AD patients (mini mental state examination < 21) showed the highest CSF orexin-A levels, whereas NT1 patients showed the lowest CSF orexin-A levels. Correlation between CSF levels of Aβ42 and orexin-A was found only in healthy subjects (r = 0.26; p = 0.01), and not in narcolepsy or AD patients. This lack of correlation in both diseases may be explained by the pathology itself since the correlation between these two biomarkers is evident only in the healthy subjects. This study adds to the present literature by further documenting the interplay between orexinergic neurotransmission and cerebral Aβ dynamics, possibly sustained by sleep.