Infrared reflectance spectroscopy (IRS), an analytical method for characterizing geologic materials, is becoming more commonly applied to geothermal energy applications. However, few case studies are available in the literature and are restricted to relatively few volcanic/geologic environments. We present an interpretation of reservoir mineralogy using IRS on drill cuttings from an active magmatic-heat-sourced geothermal system hosted in metamorphic rocks known as “The Geysers”, located in northern California and operated by Calpine Corp. Wavelength ranges investigated include the Short Wave Infrared (SWIR; 1000–2500 nm) and the Long Wave Infrared (LWIR; 2.5–20 μm). We apply this technique to a 2848 m-deep geothermal production well in the northwest Geysers, inferred to overlie a Holocene intrusion and zone of partial melt as indicated by geophysics. We utilized this non-destructive technique to analyze every drill-cuttings sample (3000+ measurements collected at ∼3.3 m intervals). We identify a zonation in mineralogy that changes from illite + chlorite ± kaolinite ± smectite ± calcite at shallow depths (0–1000 m), to illite + chlorite ± calcite at intermediate depths (1000–2200 m), to actinolite + biotite + chlorite ± tourmaline at greatest depths (2200–2848 m). We find the change at 2200 m is proximal to the inferred transition from the “normal” temperature reservoir (∼240 °C vapor-dominated convective zone) to the high temperature reservoir (up to 400 °C, conduction-dominated). We identify a possible association between 1900 nm H2O absorptions and current steam entry locations. The results of the SWIR and LWIR analysis are consistent with some caveats with newly collected bulk rock X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) data, and support and compliment previous work at the Geysers utilizing XRD and petrographic analysis.