Environmental regulations have recently drawn attention from fossil sources to green materials, among which sugar alcohols (SA) have particular importance due to their vast use in the nutrition, pharmaceutical, and chemical industries. Their properties and equilibrium conditions, including the extraction and solubility behavior utilizing novel solvents such as ionic liquids (ILs), are essential for developing further processes and their optimization. On account of this, the present study aims to develop a comprehensive thermodynamic approach based on simple and accurate tools such as activity coefficient models (ACMs) and equations of state (EoSs), which have not been hitherto addressed. To this end, eleven calculation schemes based on these two approaches were applied to the largest databank investigated thus far (13 SAs, 21 ILs, and 653 data points), and the performance of the models was analyzed. NRTL, free-volume Flory-Huggins (FVFH), and Redlich-Kister (RK) ACMs with different schemes, as well as athermal and ideal solution models, were evaluated and compared against well-known cubic EoSs such as Peng-Robinson (PR) and Valderrama-Patel-Teja (VPT). Benefitting from three adjustable parameters and a simple form, the three-parameter RK model yielded the best results with a 0.82 % (2.77 K) deviation in the entire databank. Moreover, employing temperature-dependent interaction parameters with FVFH ACM (3.55 K, 1.05 %), PR EoS (3.60 K, 1.07 %), and VPT EoS (3.66 K, 1.08 %) improved the accuracy of the calculations remarkably. The results of this contribution prove that thermodynamic models based on NRTL, FVFH, and RK ACMs are the best options for calculating solid–liquid conditions equilibrium of SA-IL systems with a simple and precise calculation procedure, and can therefore be employed for the simulation and optimization tools. This study investigates the most extensive SA-IL databank, a large number of models from different routes, and the nature of SA-IL pairs employing the obtained parameters.