All papers published in this volume have been reviewed through processes administered by the Editors. Reviews were conducted by expert referees to the professional and scientific standards expected of a proceedings journal published by IOP Publishing. In the first stage, every paper that submitted by the author to the morressier website were reviewed by internal reviewers and assessed based on the content suitability with the theme and scope of the 2021 AEFS Conference, writing format suitability with the IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science template, clarity of language, and similarity index by turn it in. In addition, the contents of the paper must be the result of a research. Unsuitable paper and paper that requiring major revision based on the review results were immediately rejected. There were 186 papers submitted in this stage. After that, in the second stage, all papers (159 papers) that passed in the first stage were reviewed by the Scientific Committee and assessed based on content suitability with the theme and scope of the 2021 AEFS Conference, clarity of language use and delivery methods, and the paper contents (introduction, method, discussion of results research, and conclusions) related to originality, innovation, technical soundness, applicability, clarity of presentation, and relevance more deeply. In addition, the editorial team also assessed the suitability of the writing format, refer to the IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science format such as reference writing, spacing, font size, font type, and others. Papers that didn’t meet the standard of research results based on the reviewer’s assessment were rejected at this stage, while papers that require revision were returned to the author for revision based on the notes on the review results through the AEFS system. The results of the revised paper were directly submitted by the author to the morressier system no later than October 26th, 2021. Papers that successfully passed this stage received a temporary Letter of Acceptance (LOA) with several acceptance requirements that must be met. To complete the requirements, author must revise the paper in accordance with the revised notes of the review results from reviewers within a predetermined time, pay the administration payments, and present the paper at the 5th International Conference on Agriculture, Environment, and Food Security (AEFS) in 2021. Author who has paid the administration payment received the invitation to present his paper at the 5th International Conference on Agriculture, Environment and Food Security (AEFS). Moreover, paper that has completed the administration payment and was presented at the 4th International Conference on Agriculture, Environment, and Food Security (AEFS) 2021, still needed revision based on the results of the second stage review. The results of these revision were assessed by 46 internal reviewers based on the suitability of the revision with revised notes and recommendations from reviewers and editors at the second stage. In addition, the editorial team also re-checked the paper similarity index by turn it in. Then, the paper would be returned to the author to be corrected until it met all revision notes and recommendations from reviewers and editors. There were 159 papers to review in this stage. This stage was carried out on November 19th to December 18th 2021. There were 142 papers that successfully passed this stage. Finally, the quick skimming process was carried out in the final review to ensure the feasibility of the paper for publication and filter out minor errors in terms of paper content that still existed before the paper was sent to the publisher. At this stage, the editorial team once again checked the final similarity index by turn it in to ensure that the paper met the publication standards. This stage was carried out on December 18th 2021 to January 18th 2022. The editorial team also reviewed the paper and did the final editing process before sent the papers to the publisher. The final editing process was carried out on January 20th to March 29th 2022. There were 142 papers that met the publication standards and were sent to the publisher.1. Type of peer review: Double Anonymous2. Conference submission management system: Morressier3. Number of submissions received: 1864. Number of submissions sent for review: 1595. Number of submissions accepted: 1426. Acceptance Rate (Submissions Accepted / Submissions Received × 100): 76.34%7. Average number of reviews per paper: 2.008. Total number of reviewers involved: 469. Contact person for queries:Name: R. B. Moh. Ibrahim Fatoni, S.Pi., M.P.Affiliation: Universitas Sumatera UtaraEmail: aefs@usu.ac.id
Read full abstract