Charge-inversion Reactions Research Articles

Enhancing sensitivity in miniature mass spectrometry analysis via dicationic ionic liquid-based matrix-assisted ionization and charge inversion reactions

Miniature mass spectrometry analysis with enhanced sensitivity via dicationic ionic liquid-based matrix-assisted ionization and charge inversion reactions.

Charge Inversion Ion/Ion Reactions Coupled to Ion Mobility/Mass Spectrometry: Oligosaccharides.

Various ion mobility-based separation techniques and instruments have been recently developed to increase the operational resolution of ion mobility separations, especially of isomers and isobars. In addition to developments in instrumentation, different covalent and noncovalent derivatization techniques have helped achieve effective separations by magnifying minor differences in collision cross section. Among these methodologies is host-guest complex formation and, a new development presented herein, charge inversion ion-ion reactions coupled to ion mobility separations. We used these methods to enable formation of complexes between isomeric deprotonated oligosaccharides and alkaline earth metals (in solution) and alkaline earth metal-trisphenanthroline complexes (in vacuo), observing minor shifts in ion mobility arrival times for the charge inversion reaction products as well as unique mobility fingerprints indicative of separations of α/β anomers of disaccharides. For example, we have demonstrated separations between reducing disaccharides such as lactose and lactulose and nonreducing disaccharides. We also observed separations based on the pyranose/furanose configurations of the isomers. These results suggest the potential for ion/ion reactions to enable isomer separation of biomolecules from various compound classes using ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS).

Localization of cyclopropyl groups and alkenes within glycerophospholipids using gas-phase ion/ion chemistry.

Shotgun lipid analysis using electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) is a common approach for the identification and characterization of glycerophohspholipids GPs. ESI-MS/MS, with the aid of collision-induced dissociation (CID), enables the characterization of GP species at the headgroup and fatty acyl sum compositional levels. However, important structural features that are often present, such as carbon-carbon double bond(s) and cyclopropane ring(s), can be difficult to determine. Here, we report the use of gas-phase charge inversion reactions that, in combination with CID, allow for more detailed structural elucidation of GPs. CID of a singly deprotonated GP, [GP - H]- , generates FA anions, [FA - H]- . The fatty acid anions can then react with doubly charged cationic magnesium tris-phenanthroline complex, [Mg(Phen)3 ]2+ , to form charge inverted complex cations of the form [FA - H + MgPhen2 ]+ . CID of the complex generates product ion spectral patterns that allow for the identification of carbon-carbon double bond position(s) as well as the sites of cyclopropyl position(s) in unsaturated lipids. This approach to determining both double bond and cyclopropane positions is demonstrated with GPs for the first time using standards and is applied to lipids extracted from Escherichia coli.

Selective Schiff base formation via gas-phase ion/ion reactions to enable differentiation of isobaric lipids in imaging mass spectrometry.

The separation and identification of lipids in complex mixtures are critical to deciphering their cellular functions. Failure to resolve isobaric compounds (e.g., via high mass resolution or tandem mass spectrometry) can result in incorrect identifications in mass spectrometry experiments. In imaging mass spectrometry, unresolved peaks can also result in composite images of multiple compounds, giving inaccurate depictions of molecular distributions. Gas-phase ion/ion reactions can be used to selectively react with specific chemical functional groups on a target analyte, thereby extracting it from a complex mixture and shifting its m/z value to an unobstructed region of the mass range. Herein, we use selective Schiff base formation via a novel charge inversion ion/ion reaction to purify phosphatidylserines from other isobaric (i.e., same nominal mass) lipids and reveal their singular distributions in imaging mass spectrometry. The selective Schiff base formation between singly deprotonated phosphatidylserine (PS) lipid anions and doubly charged N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-N,N'-bis(6-oxohexyl)hexane-1,6-diaminium (TMODA) cations is performed using a modified commercial dual source hybrid Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometer. This process is demonstrated using the isobaric lipids [PS 40:6 - H]- (m/z 834.528) and [SHexCer d38:1 - H]- (m/z 834.576), which produces [PS 40:6 + TMODA - H - H2O]+ (m/z 1186.879), and [SHexCer d38:1 + TMODA-H]+ (m/z 1204.938) product ions following the gas-phase charge inversion reaction. These product ions differ by roughly 18Da in mass and are easily separated by low mass resolution analysis, while the isobaric precursor ions require roughly 45,000 mass resolving power (full-width at half maximum) to separate. Imaging mass spectrometry using targeted gas-phase ion/ion reactions shows distinct spatial distributions for the separated lipid product ions relative to the composite images of the unseparated precursor ions.

Localization of Carbon-Carbon Double Bond and Cyclopropane Sites in Cardiolipins via Gas-Phase Charge Inversion Reactions.

Cardiolipins (CLs) are comprised of two phosphatic acid moieties bound to a central glycerol backbone and are substituted with four acyl chains. Consequently, a vast number of distinct CL structures are possible in different biological contexts, representing a significant analytical challenge. Electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) has become a widely used approach for the detection, characterization, and quantitation of complex lipids, including CLs. Central to this approach is fragmentation of the [CLs - H]- or [CL - 2H]2- anions by collision-induced dissociation (CID). Product ions in the resulting tandem mass spectra confirm the CL subclass assignment and reveal the numbers of carbons and degrees of unsaturation in each of the acyl chains. Conventional CID, however, affords limited structural elucidation of the fatty acyl chains, failing to discriminate isomers arising from different site(s) of unsaturation or cyclopropanation and potentially obscuring their metabolic origins. Here, we report the application of charge inversion ion/ion chemistry in the gas phase to enhance the structural elucidation of CLs. Briefly, CID of [CL - H]2- anions generated via negative ion ESI allowed for the assignment of individual fatty acyl substituents and phosphatidic acid moieties. Next, gas-phase derivatization of the resulting CL product ions, including fatty acyl carboxylate anions, was effected with gas-phase ion/ion charge inversion reactions with tris-phenanthroline magnesium reagent dications. Subsequent isolation and activation of the charge-inverted fatty acyl complex cations permitted the localization of both carbon-carbon double bond and cyclopropane motifs within each of the four acyl chains of CLs. This approach was applied to the de novo elucidation of unknown CLs in a biological extract revealing distinct isomeric populations and regiochemical relationships between double bonds and carbocyles.

Identification of Phosphatidylcholine Isomers in Imaging Mass Spectrometry Using Gas-Phase Charge Inversion Ion/Ion Reactions.

Gas-phase ion/ion reactions have been enabled on a commercial dual source, hybrid QhFT-ICR mass spectrometer for use during imaging mass spectrometry experiments. These reactions allow for the transformation of the ion type most readily generated from the tissue surface to an ion type that gives improved chemical structural information upon tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) without manipulating the tissue sample. This process is demonstrated via the charge inversion reaction of phosphatidylcholine (PC) lipid cations generated from rat brain tissue via matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) with 1,4-phenylenedipropionic acid (PDPA) reagent dianions generated via electrospray ionization (ESI). Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of the resulting demethylated PC product anions allows for the determination of the lipid fatty acyl tail identities and positions, which is not possible via CID of the precursor lipid cations. The abundance of lipid isomers revealed by this workflow is found to vary significantly in different regions of the brain. As each isoform may have a unique cellular function, these results underscore the importance of accurately separating and identifying the many isobaric and isomeric lipids and metabolites that can complicate image interpretation and spectral analysis.

Generation of Multiply Charged Protein Anions from Multiply Charged Protein Cations via Gas-Phase Ion/Ion Reactions.

We report a novel charge inversion ion/ion reaction that converts multiply charged protein cations to multiply charged protein anions via a single ion/ion collision using highly charged anions derived from nanoelectrospray ionization (nESI) of hyaluronic acids (HAs). This type of charge inversion reaction is demonstrated with cations derived from cytochrome c, apo-myoglobin, and carbonic anhydrase (CA) cations. For example, the reaction has been demonstrated to convert the [CA+22H]22+ carbonic anhydrase cation to a distribution of anions as high in absolute charge as [CA-19H]19-. Ion/ion reactions involving multiply charged ions of opposite polarity have previously been observed to result predominantly in the attachment of the reactant ions. All mechanisms for ion/ion charge inversion involving low energy ions proceed via the formation of a long-lived complex. Factors that underlie the charge inversion of protein cations to high anionic charge states in reaction with HA anions are hypothesized to include: (i) the relatively high charge densities of the HA anions that facilitate the extraction of multiple protons from the protein leading to multiply charged protein anions, (ii) the relatively high sum of absolute charges of the reactants that leads to high initial energies in the ion/ion complex, and (iii) the relatively high charge of the ion/ion complex following the multiple proton transfers that tends to destabilize the complex.

Toward Complete Structure Elucidation of Glycerophospholipids in the Gas Phase through Charge Inversion Ion/Ion Chemistry.

Shotgun lipidomics has recently gained popularity for lipid analysis. Conventionally, shotgun analysis of glycerophospholipids via direct electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) provides glycerophospholipid (GPL) class (i.e., headgroup composition) and fatty acyl composition. Reliant on low-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID), traditional ESI-MS/MS fails to define fatty acyl regiochemistry along the glycerol backbone or carbon-carbon double bond position(s) in unsaturated fatty acyl substituents. Therefore, isomeric GPLs are often unresolved, representing a significant challenge for shotgun-MS approaches. We developed a top-down shotgun-MS method utilizing gas-phase ion/ion charge inversion chemistry that provides near-complete GPL structural identification. First, in negative ion mode, CID of mass-selected GPL anions generates fatty acyl carboxylate anions via fragmentation of ester bonds linking the fatty acyl substituents at the sn-1 and sn-2 positions of the glycerol backbone. Product anions, including fatty acyl carboxylate ions, were then derivatized in the mass spectrometer via an ion/ion charge inversion reaction with tris-phenanthroline magnesium dications. Subsequent CID of charge-inverted fatty acyl complex cations yielded isomer-specific product ion spectra that permit (i) unambiguous assignment of carbon-carbon double bond position(s) and (ii) relative quantitation of isomeric fatty acyl substituents. The outlined strategy was applied to the analysis of targeted GPLs extracted from human plasma, including several proposed plasma biomarkers. A single experiment thus facilitates assignment of the GPL headgroup, fatty acyl composition, carbon-carbon double bond position(s) in unsaturated fatty acyl chains, and, in some cases, fatty acyl sn-position and relative abundances for isomeric fatty acyl substituents. Ultimately, this MSn platform paired with ion/ion chemistry permitted identification of major, and some minor, isomeric contributors that are unresolved using conventional ESI-MS/MS.

Dual-Polarity Ion Trap Mass Spectrometry: Dynamic Monitoring and Controlling Gas-phase Ion-Ion Reactions.

A dual-polarity linear ion trap (LIT) mass spectrometer was developed in this study, and the method for simultaneously controlling and detecting cations and anions was proposed and realized in the LIT. With the application of an additional dipolar DC field on the ejection electrodes of an LIT, dual-polarity mass spectra could be obtained, which include both the mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio and charge polarity information of an ion. Compared with conventional method, the ion ejection and detection efficiency could also be improved by about one-fold. Furthermore, ion-ion reactions within the LIT could be dynamically controlled and monitored by manipulating the distributions of ions with opposite charge polarities. This method was then used to control and study the reaction kinetics of ion-ion reactions, including electron transfer dissociation (ETD) and charge inversion reactions. A dual-polarity collision-induced dissociation (CID) experiment was proposed and performed to enhance the sequence coverage of a peptide ion. Ion trajectory simulations were also carried out for concept validation and system optimization. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Gas-Phase Chemical Separation of Phosphatidylcholine and Phosphatidylethanolamine Cations via Charge Inversion Ion/Ion Chemistry.

The [M + H](+) cations formed upon electrospray ionization of the glycerophospholipids phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) show distinct reactivities upon gas-phase reactions with doubly deprotonated 1,4-phenylenedipropionic acid (PDPA). PC cations undergo charge inversion via adduct formation with subsequent methyl cation and proton transfer to the acid to yield [PC - CH3](-) anions. These demethylated PC anions fragment upon ion trap collision-induced dissociation (CID) to yield products that reveal fatty acid chain lengths and degrees of unsaturation. PE cations, on the other hand, undergo charge inversion via double proton transfer to the two carboxylate moieties in doubly deprotonated PDPA to yield [PE - H](-) anions. These anions also fragment upon ion trap CID to yield product ions indicative of chain lengths and degrees of unsaturation in the fatty acyl moieties. Advantage is taken of this distinct reactivity to separate isomeric and isobaric PC and PE cations present in mass spectra of lipid mixtures. A cation precursor ion population containing a mixture of PE and PC cations is mass-selected and subjected to ion/ion charge inversion reactions that result in separation of PC and PE anions into different mass-to-charge ratios. Mass selection and subsequent ion trap CID of the lipid anions allows for the characterization of the isomeric lipids within each subclass. The charge inversion approach described here is demonstrated to provide increased signal-to-noise ratios for detection of PCs and PEs relative to the standard negative ionization approach as well as improved mixture analysis performance.

Gas-Phase Bioconjugation of Peptides via Ion/Ion Charge Inversion: Schiff Base Formation on the Conversion of Cations to Anions

The selective covalent modification of singly protonated peptides in the gas-phase via ion/ion charge inversion reactions is demonstrated. Doubly deprotonated 4-formyl-1,3-benzene disulfonic acid serves as a reagent anion for forming a Schiff base via the reaction of a primary amine on the peptide and the aldehyde functionality of the reagent anion. The process is initiated by the formation of an ion/ion complex comprised of the two reactants. Ion trap collisional activation of the complex results in loss of water from the intermediate that gives rise to Schiff base formation. N-terminally acetylated peptides with no lysine residues do not undergo covalent bond formation upon reaction with the reagent anion. Rather, the adduct species simply loses the reagent either as a neutral species or as a deprotonated species. The ability to modify singly protonated peptide ions covalently and selectively opens up new possibilities for the analysis of peptides and, possibly, other analyte species with primary amine functionalities.

Transmission mode ion/ion reactions in the radiofrequency-only ion guide of hybrid tandem mass spectrometers.

Transmission mode ion/ion reactions have been performed within the first quadrupole, the Q0 radiofrequency (RF)-only quadrupole, of two types of hybrid tandem mass spectrometers (viz., triple quadrupole/linear ion trap and QqTOF instruments). These transmission mode reactions involved the storage of either the reagent species and the transmission of the analyte species through the Q0 quadrupole for charge inversion reactions or the storage of the analyte ions and transmission of the reagent ions as in charge reduction experiments. A key advantage to the use of transmission mode ion/ion reactions is that they do not require any instrument hardware modifications to provide interactions of oppositely charged ions and can be implemented in any instrument that contains a quadrupole or linear ion trap. The focus of this work was to investigate the potential of using the RF-only quadrupole ion guide positioned prior to the first mass-resolving element in a tandem mass spectrometer for ion/ion reactions. Two types of exemplary experiments have been demonstrated. One involved a charge inversion reaction and the other involved a charge reduction reaction in conjunction with ion parking. Ion/ion reactions proved to be readily implemented in Q0 thereby adding significantly greater experimental flexibility in the use of ion/ion reaction experiments with hybrid tandem mass spectrometers.

Conversion of multiple analyte cation types to a single analyte anion type via ion/ion charge inversion

Charge inversion ion/ion reactions can convert several cation types associated with a single analyte molecule to a single anion type for subsequent mass analysis. Specifically, analyte ions present with one of a variety of cationizing agents, such as an excess proton, excess sodium ion, or excess potassium ion, can all be converted to the deprotonated molecule, provided that a stable anion can be generated for the analyte. Multiply deprotonated species that are capable of exchanging a proton for a metal ion serve as the reagent anions for the reaction. This process is demonstrated here for warfarin and for a glutathione conjugate. Examples for several other glutathione conjugates are provided as supplementary material to demonstrate the generality of the reaction. In the case of glutathione conjugates, multiple metal ions can be associated with the singly-charged analyte due to the presence of two carboxylate groups. The charge inversion reaction involves the removal of the excess cationizing agent, as well as any metal ions associated with anionic groups to yield a singly deprotonated analyte molecule. The ability to convert multiple cation types to a single anion type is analytically desirable in cases in which the analyte signal is distributed among several cation types, as is common in the electrospray ionization of solutions with relatively high salt contents. For analyte species that undergo efficient charge inversion, such as glutathione conjugates, there is the additional potential advantage for significantly improved signal-to-noise ratios when species that give rise to 'chemical noise' in the positive ion spectrum do not undergo efficient charge inversion.

Reagent Anions for Charge Inversion of Polypeptide/Protein Cations in the Gas Phase

Various reagent anions capable of converting polypeptide cations to anions via ion/ion reactions have been investigated. The major charge inversion reaction channels include multiple proton transfer and adduct formation. Dianions composed of sulfonate groups as the negative charge carriers show essentially exclusive adduct formation in converting protonated peptides and proteins to anions. Dianions composed of carboxylate groups, on the other hand, show far more charge inversion via multiple proton transfer, with the degree of adduct formation dependent upon both the size of the polypeptide and the spacings between carboxylate groups in the dianion. More highly charged carboxylate-containing anions, such as those derived from carboxylate-terminated polyamidoamine half-generation dendrimers show charge inversion to give anion charges as high in magnitude as -4, with the degree of adduct formation being inversely related to dendrimer generation. All observations can be interpreted on the basis of charge inversion taking place via a long-lived chemical complex. The lifetime of this complex is related to the strengths and numbers of the interactions of the reactants in the complex. Calculations with model systems are fully consistent with sulfonate groups giving rise to more stable complexes. The kinetic stability of the complex can also be affected by the presence of electrostatic repulsion if it is multiply charged. In general, this situation destabilizes the complex and reduces the likelihood for observation of adducts. The findings highlight the characteristics of multiply charged anions that play roles in determining the nature of charge inversion products associated with protonated peptides and proteins.

Increasing the negative charge of a macroanion in the gas phase via sequential charge inversion reactions.

Protonated and deprotonated biological molecules in the gas phase play an important role in life sciences research. The structural information accessible from the ions is highly dependent upon their charge states. Therefore, it is desirable to develop means for increasing absolute charge states, particularly for ionization methods, such as MALDI, that yield relatively low charge ions. The work presented here demonstrates the formation of a doubly deprotonated polypeptide or oligonucleotide ion (dianion) from a singly deprotonated analogue via two sequential ion/ion proton-transfer reactions involving charge inversion. The high exoergicity and the large cross section arising from the long-range attractive Coulomb potential of ion/ion reactions make this process plausible. In this example, an overall efficiency of conversion of singly charged ions to doubly charged ions of roughly 8% for polypeptide was noted while lower efficiency (roughly 2%) observed with an oligonucleotide is likely due to a greater degree of neutralization. No other approach to increasing the net negative charge of an anion in the gas phase has as yet been reported.

Two ion/ion charge inversion steps to form a doubly protonated peptide from a singly protonated peptide in the gas phase.

An approach is described to increase the degree of protonation of a polypeptide ion in the gas phase. Sequential charge inversion reactions involving the reactions of oppositely charged ions are used to yield a net increase in ion charge. The approach is illustrated here with the conversion of singly protonated bradykinin to doubly protonated bradykinin. The first step involves conversion of the singly protonated peptide to the singly deprotonated peptide via reactions with multiply charged anions derived from carboxylate-terminated dendrimers. Some of the singly deprotonated peptide was then converted to doubly protonated peptide via reactions with multiply charged cations derived from amino-terminated dendrimers. The overall approach is illustrative of a general strategy for increasing the absolute charge states of large ions in the gas phase.

Cationic and anionic states of CF, CCl, SiF and SiCl. Some new information derived using translational energy spectroscopy

Abstract Translational-energy spectroscopy was applied to collisional-excitation and charge-inversion reactions of CF+, CCl+, SiF+ and SiCl+ in order to gain energetic and bond-length information about the anionic and excited-cationic states of the title molecules. The excitation spectra revealed that the a 3 Π state, known in CCl+ and SiCl+, has a term energy of 4.85 ± 0.15 eV in CF+ and 4.70 ± 0.20 eV in SiF+, while the 11Π state, known in CCl+, is not below the dissociation threshold in CF+, SiF+ and SiCl+. These data, and bond-length estimates for the a 3 Π states, are consistent with documented ab initio predictions except for re of CF + ( a 3 Π) which seems to be larger than 1.21 A. Charge-inversion spectra indicated that beams of monohalide cations formed from the tetrahalides, contained substantial proportions of a 3 Π- state ions, and, in the case of CCl, SiF and SiCl, the broadness of spectral peaks was taken as evidence for the stability of the a 1 Δ- state anion. Adiabatic electron affinities were deduced to be 0.49 ± 0.15 eV, 0.89 ± 0.20 eV, 1.34 ± 0.30 eV and 1.40 ± 0.30 eV for the title molecules, respectively.

Electron affinities of BH, B 2, BC and BN molecules determined using charge inversion spectrometry

The anions BH −, B − 2, BC − and BN − have been observed as products of charge-inversion reactions of the respective cations formed from BH 3, B 2H 6, B(OCH 3) 3 and BH 3NH 3. The spectra, recorded using CS 2 target gas, have forms which are consistent with documented ab initio energies and equilibrium bond lengths determined for these anions. In particular, given the theoretical ionisation energies, the spectra establish the electron affinities for BH and BN, and average electron-attachment energies for B 2 and BC (where multiple bound anionic states are populated) as being 0.30 ± 0.25, 2.9 ± 0.3, 1.3 ± 0.4, (1.8 eV estimated electron affinity) and 2.4 ± 0.3 eV, (2.8 eV estimated electron affinity) respectively. The spectrum of B +/CS 2 is also discussed.

Observation, in mass spectra and charge-inversion spectra, of the anions of some diatomic species containing B, Si or P atoms

The title anions are mostly unknown experimentally, but many are predicted to have stable states. A search was therefore made, and the following fifteen anions were found in the accurate-mass spectra of the given precursors: BH - B - 2 from reduced BBr 3 BC - from B(OCH 3) 3; BN - and BS - from BBr 3 (or BH 3) complexed with NH 3 and S 2CI 2 respectively; SiC - and SiO - from CH 3Si(OCH 3) 3; SiN - from (CH 3) 3SiN 3; SiX -(X = F, or Cl) from SiX 4; PC - from CL 2PCH 3; PN - and PCl - from P 3N 3Cl 6; PF - from HPF 6 (aq.) and PS - from P 4S 10. These anions were also observed to be formed in charge-inversion reactions of the cations. The anions BF -, BCl - and BP - were searched for but not found. Charge inversion spectra; Double charge transfer; Diatomic anions.

Observation, in mass spectra and charge-inversion spectra, of the anions of some diatomic species containing B, Si or P atoms

The title anions are mostly unknown experimentally, but many are predicted to have stable states. A search was therefore made, and the following fifteen anions were found in the accurate-mass spectra of the given precursors: BH − B − 2 from reduced BBr 3; BC − from B(OCH 3) 3; BN − and BS − from BBr 3 (or BH 3) complexed with NH 3 and S 2Cl 2 respectively; SiC − and SiO − from CH 3Si(OCH 3) 3; SiN − from (CH 3) 3SiN 3; SiX − (X = F, or Cl) from SiX 4; PC − from CL 2PCH 3; PN − and PCl − from P 3N 3Cl 6; PF − from HPF 6 (aq.) and PS − from P 4S 10. These anions were also observed to be formed in charge-inversion reactions of the cations. The anions BF −, BCl − and BP − were searched for but not found.