Methane from anaerobic fermentation in the rumen of cattle is a major contributor to greenhouse gases (50–60%). Methanogenesis is an important process in the ruminants as it scavenges hydrogen produced during the anaerobic fermentation of sugars in the rumen and, thereby, balances the fermentation process. This work focuses on mitigation of methane production in rumen by bioaugmentation with hydrogenotrophic acetogenic strains thus, channelizing hydrogen towards acetate instead of methane. For this two acetogenic cultures: Acetobacterium woodii and a stable consortium from a baby kangaroo feces sample were used as potential competitors for hydrogen-carbon dioxide against rumen methanogens. Addition of Acetobacterium woodii or an acetogenic kangaroo consortium had only limited effect on methane production from continuously grown rumen cultures. However, one-time treatment with an inhibitor of methanogenesis (2-bromoethanesulfonic acid), along with addition of either of the two acetogenic cultures resulted in well-functioning fermentation process with acetogenesis with no methane production. Monod's growth kinetics studies were done to test the ability of selected homoacetogens to compete against methanogens for hydrogen. The results show a lower Ks value for the methanogenic culture (0.737 mM hydrogen) compared to the Ks values for Acetobacterium woodii and the kangaroo consortia of 6.844 mM and 3.788 mM hydrogen, respectively. The Vmax was found to be similar for the methanogenic and kangaroo culture (0.381 mM/h and 0.331 mM/h, respectively) but lower for Acetobacterium woodii (0.217 mM/h).