Narrating the BlockadeYoung Female Diarists and the Siege of Leningrad Caroline Fernandez (bio) and David Brandenberger (bio) Alexis Peri, The War Within: Diaries from the Siege of Leningrad. 384 pp. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2017. ISBN-13 978-0674971554. $29.95. "War! It's awful! This is an unprecedented war. Without seeing and hearing the explosions of shells and bombs, you'd never believe and imagine what war is. The 20th century! People are so brutal to one another in this century!!! That cursed night of 22 June! How many deaths it has brought."1 So 18-yearold Berta Zlotnikova opened her diary on 1 October 1941. At the time, Zlotnikova was working in a Leningrad factory; later, she would move on to serve in a hospital and then as a leader of a pioneer troop. In school, she had dreamed of becoming a writer or journalist, but the war, she wrote, "ruined all my hopes."2 Nazi Germany's declaration of war on the USSR on 22 June 1941 literally confronted Soviet society with an existential crisis. Within the historic northern capital of Leningrad, the war would ruin millions of lives and livelihoods before its end in 1945. In September 1941, Leningrad was surrounded by Axis forces. This blockade was not broken until 872 days later, in January 1944, and is known to this day as the longest and most destructive siege in modern history. Statistically, the consequences were horrific: Leningraders trapped in the city died at shocking rates, partly from shelling and bombing but overwhelmingly from starvation and cold, especially during the first winter of 1941–42. Ultimately, it is estimated that around 800,000 civilians died during the blockade—around 40 percent of the city's prewar population (4). [End Page 865] Statistics are often cited to evoke the enormity of the blockade and its consequences, but it is important to consider individual experience as well. Alexis Peri does just that in The War Within, a monograph in which she analyzes the unpublished siege-era diaries of 125 Leningraders (as well as a number of published ones). In this book, Peri tackles some ambitious questions: How did everyday Leningraders respond to the blockade as it occurred? Why did Leningraders keep diaries during the siege? Did the blockade, which assumes such momentous proportions in hindsight, challenge the Soviet system and the mentalité of Homo sovieticus in real time? If so, did Leningraders sense these changes as they transpired? And did the post-facto official Soviet narrative of the siege reflect ordinary people's experiences? Peri's study is significant as one of the first incisive analyses of siege-era diaries as well as for its critical comparison of the diaries' themes with those of official Soviet narratives.3 She touches on the consequences of the siege on both the individual and societal levels, considering popular perceptions of everything from food, work, sacrifice, and the self to identity, social hierarchy, and history itself. Ultimately, Peri concludes: "Diarists were forced to reckon with core concepts, practices, and narratives that shaped life in the Soviet Union. This critical examination would have made them unsuitable as the documentary basis for the regime's celebratory narratives of the siege in the postwar era" (4). Such sources ultimately allow Peri to offer a counterpoint to the official, heroic narrative of the siege, presenting a more nuanced picture of the everyday struggle of Leningraders to survive and confront the titular "war within."4 [End Page 866] This review essay surveys an array of themes detailed in Peri's book and compares them to those found in a different, smaller sample of 13 diaries kept by Leningrad women between the ages of 17 and 25 (sources not examined in The War Within, with one exception).5 In doing so, this review investigates which themes identified by Peri are truly universal and which ought to be considered more specific to her cohort of diarists. The cohort of diarists chosen for this comparative study of Peri's findings was selected purposefully. First, despite Leningrad's population skewing female during the siege, scholarship has often underrepresented women's experiences in such wartime contexts.6 Second, younger authors...
Read full abstract