There is a lack of information on the reliability of smart soil moisture sensor-based irrigation controllers for autonomous urban landscape irrigation management using recycled water where water conservation is required, which is the main objective of this study. A three-year turfgrass irrigation research trial (2019–2021) using tertiary-treated recycled water (mean EC = 1.18 dS/m, pH = 7.5) was conducted in Irvine, California, USA. A total of 12 irrigation treatments were designed, including six soil moisture-based thresholds (for triggering and terminating irrigation events) × two irrigation frequency treatments (restricted versus on-demand). Weekly NDVI and canopy temperature data were collected during the summer irrigation season to assess the impact of irrigation treatments on the overall health and quality of 'Tifgreen 328' hybrid bermudagrass. Soil salinity and sodium adsorption ratio (SAR) were measured before and after the summer irrigation seasons. Findings revealed statistically significant effects of irrigation levels and irrigation frequency restrictions on NDVI over the three years. The temperature difference (dT) between turfgrass and air (Tc - Ta) was significantly affected by irrigation levels throughout the three years, while irrigation frequency restrictions showed a significant effect in the years 2021 and 2022. On-demand irrigation resulted in a 10% reduction in temperature difference values during the study period compared to restricted irrigation. Variations in soil salinity levels were observed during the experimental periods; however, both salinity and SAR increased as the study progressed. Results indicate that fully autonomous hybrid bermudagrass irrigation with recycled water, based on recommended soil moisture thresholds of 75% of field capacity over an extended period in a semiarid climate, may lead to unacceptable turfgrass quality.