We previously demonstrated significant gender and racial differences when self-Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS) and spouse-reported ESS were compared. In this study, we investigate whether gender specific self-ESS scores correlate with the objective measures of sleep quality. Seventy-nine patient–spouse pairs completed the ESS questionnaires after which patients underwent polysomnographic testing (PSG). The correlation between ESS results and the PSG-obtained measurements of sleep efficiency (SE), sleep arousal index (AI), and apnea hypopnea index (AHI) were evaluated by calculating Pearson’s and Spearman’s correlation coefficients. Differences within patient–spouse pairs were evaluated using Wilcoxon’s Rank Sum Test. Our results indicated significant difference between patient-reported and spouse-reported scores for all patient age/gender groups except for female patients over 60. Significant correlations were seen between female patient-reported ESS scores, but not their spouse-reported ESS scores, and all three objective measures of sleep. In contrast, there was no significant correlation between male patient, and spouse-reported ESS scores and SE, AI, and AHI. The answers of female patients to individual sleepiness scenarios on ESS strongly correlated with at least one of the PSG-obtained values. In male patients, only one sleepiness scenario correlated with AHI, and their spouse-reported answers to specific ESS questions correlated with patients’ SE. Self-reported ESS is an effective marker of sleep quality only in female patients. For male patients, self-reported and spouse-reported answers to the specific questions of the ESS rather than the total ESS score are better markers of sleep quality.
Read full abstract