In the realm of carbon fiber research, a variety of structural configurations is noted, comprising crystalline, noncrystalline, and semicrystalline forms. Recent investigations into this domain have revealed an array of intriguing phases of carbon, among which amorphous graphite is the most notable for its unique mechanical, thermal, and electrical properties that arise from its inherent topological disorders. In this study, we utilized the ReaxFF molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the carbonization and graphitization processes involved in the production of amorphous graphite from benzothiophene, a sulfur-containing polar aromatic precursor. We developed C/H/S ReaxFF force field parameters to describe the high-temperature chemistry of benzothiophene. Our investigation reveals the reaction mechanisms, providing critical insights into the underlying chemical processes toward the formation of amorphous graphite and the structural characteristics of the end products. The formation of volatile gaseous molecules and their continuous elimination led to the development of noncontinuous layered graphite structures analogous to amorphous graphite consisting of pentagons, hexagons, and heptagons. These findings offer unprecedented insights into the carbonization and graphitization processes of sulfur-containing heavy-end aromatic feedstock. This knowledge lays the groundwork for advancing synthesis methods and developing amorphous graphite materials with specific properties.