This trilogy on political parties involves developmental and comparative analysis across nations, across time, and across parties. The excellent volume edited by LaPalombara and Weiner contains essays on European parties by Hans Daalder, Giovanni Sartori, Otto Kirchheimer, and Stein Rokkan; on American parties by William N. Chambers and Morton Grodzins; on Middle Eastern parties by Dankwart A. Rustow and Leonard Binder; and on African parties by Immanuel Wallerstein and Rupert Emerson. Lucian W. Pye contributes a general essay on Asian party systems, and Robert E. Scott does the same for Latin America. LaPalombara and Weiner open and close the collection with attempted theoretical statements, first on the conditions facilitating the development of political parties and then on the impact of parties on political development. For the editors the concept political development remains elusive, but what they mainly have in mind is the notion, already adumbrated by Lipset, Almond, Pye, and others, that political development involves a political system passing through crises-crises of identity, legitimacy, integration, participation, distribution, and so forth. Speculating about how some of these systemic crises may have affected the development of political parties provides, to some extent, the major thread for the contributions to this collection of essays. Still, the essays are highly eclectic. Daalder's paper contains a delightful comment on elitist theories; Sartori's pole-vaulting is exhilarating, and this essay provides a good, hard-headed argument for retaining in the comparative analysis of parties an emphasis on structural and procedural engineering; Kirchheimer presents a very thoughtful functional approach; and Grodzins demonstrates the limitations of focusing on party cleavage and consensus for explanations of political change. Rokkan's paper, my nomination for the best of the bunch, contains some very interesting empirical data on Norwegian parties and a ukase which strikes me as the best advice in the book: Only through . .
Read full abstract