This study focuses on the potentiostatic electrodeposition of copper indium and cadmium sulfide (CuS, In2S3, and CdS) thin films on copper substrates, aiming to develop efficient electrocatalysts for the electrochemical reduction of CO2 and sustainable hydrogen generation. Utilizing Cu Kα radiation for X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis, the crystal structures of the electrodeposited films were confirmed, revealing well-defined crystalline phases. The films exhibited average particle sizes of 55.99 nm for CuS, 50.37 nm for In2S3, and 63.51 nm for CdS. Cyclic voltammetry and chronoamperometry were employed to optimize the deposition parameters, ensuring efficient nucleation and growth of the metal sulfide films. The electrochemical performance of the synthesized electrocatalysts was rigorously tested, demonstrating their potential for CO2 reduction under optimized conditions with the highest efficiency for CdS electrodes. Additionally, the electrodeposited CuS and CdS are of the p-type, and In2S3 is of the n-type semiconductor were studied and verified by the Mott–Schottky test. CuS, In2S3, and CdS were found to have donor and acceptor concentrations (ND) of 1.68 × 106, 1.44 × 105, and 8.9 × 105 cm3, respectively. The photoelectrochemical measurements of the electrodeposited metal sulfides were studied at ambient temperature and under illumination, providing higher photocurrent responses for CdS and demonstrating its strong potential as a photoelectrode material for CO2 reduction. This work underscores the significance of facile electrochemical synthesis methods in developing cost-effective and scalable electrocatalysts, paving the way for their integration into photoelectrochemical systems for green energy applications.