Economic potential of agricultural-riparian shrub willow: An evaluation of the biomass producing capabilities and costs of cultivating Salix viminalis downslope of potato cropping systems in PEI

Abstract

Shrub willow (Salix spp.) is increasingly grown as a biomass crop and for a range of environmental applications. Merging the economic and environmental objectives of willow production may facilitate more widespread adoption by reducing production costs and justifying willow cultivation in traditional agricultural settings. Incorporating willow in agricultural-riparian transition areas, particularly in intensive or high-input agricultural systems, can enhance watercourse protection from diffuse pollutants, mitigate indirect agricultural N2O emissions, and sequester carbon. However, biomass accrual and economic feasibility needs quantification on localized scales.This study investigated the biomass accrual of 9 agricultural-riparian willow buffers in Prince Edward Island, Canada, receiving no direct fertilization. Carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus assimilation was measured in stem and root biomass, limitations on growth assessed, and benefit-cost analysis was conducted to determine opportunities for bioenergy use and deployment. First rotation agricultural-riparian Salix viminalis displayed considerable site-to-site variation in biomass production, with water availability being the primary limiting factor on growth. Mean total plant biomass and annual yield ranged from 0.54 to 7.9 kg dry matter plant−1 and 0.25–16.59 Mg ha−1 yr−1 (mean 3.9), respectively. CO2 fixation was 0.67–46.64 Mg CO2 ha−1 yr−1, of which 0.23–15.7 Mg CO2 ha−1 yr−1 was root biomass, indicative of long-term sequestration. Nitrogen and phosphorus removal was 6.05–39.1 (mean 23.3) and 1.1–4.8 (mean 2.8) kg ha−1 yr−1. Benefit-cost analysis revealed that shrub willow production can be economically viable for on-farm heating when yields exceeding 5.6 Mg dry matter ha−1yr−1 are achieved, but off-farm sale is not currently economically justified.