Abstract

The present paper is an attempt to understand the working of international aid agencies with the marginalized groups of India. I argue that the functioning of these agencies is not innocent and the same can be revealed by critical understanding of the internal dynamics of their operation, particularly in the broader field of empowerment of marginalized communities that they are engaged with. Despite the fact that the International aid agencies have their imprints in India for decades, there is no visible or substantial change in lives of the communities they seek to change. Those, particularly the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, other marginalized communities continue to be at the lower strata of the society devoid of socio- political, economic and welfare measures of the so-called egalitarian state. One reason that led to the failure of these agencies is their un(conscious) inability to understand the socio, political and cultural dynamics of Indian caste system. Without proper understanding of the caste system, one cannot comprehend the resultant systematic exclusion, which in fact led to the perennial poverty of these communities. Furthermore, the paper seeks to understand the institutional setup of these aid agencies in India and argues thereby that any developmental, reformist and empowerment agenda adopted by such agencies is inherently ‘exclusive’ and therefore bound to fail in the promises that they make. This paper critically views the aid agencies’ mainstream perception of caste discourse, their lack of will to include the members of the marginalized communities into their policymaking bodies. Moreover, I argue that any developmental intervention without the active participation of marginalized communities will be a charade in the name of charity. The paper divided into 6 sections. In the first section, I look at the role of caste in modern context, synthesizing the views of scholars such as K Sathyanarayana, Susie Tharu, G Aloysius, Gopal Guru, Sundar Sarukai, N. Sukumar and AS Ajith Kumar and argue that caste is reconfigured and more rampant in modern times. In the second section, I argue that, with the formation of Brahmanical caste based organizations across the countries, caste has become a world problem; third section is about understanding of caste in international aid agencies. In the fourth section, I draw your attention on the caste diversity and staffing practices of international aid agencies in India, which disproportionately occupied and operated by privileged sections with Brahmanic cultural capital. In the fifth section, I argue for the need of challenging the caste in conscious level to symbolic boundaries. The sixth chapter is the conclusion and seventh one is the annexure, list out the Brahmanical caste based organizations formed in the countries across the world, eighth one is the table that indicates the No diversity and No accountability in the aid agencies in India Keywords: Caste, India, Aid Agencies, Modernity, Globalization, Discrimination, Diversity

Highlights

  • Caste inequalities in Indian society basing on Chaturvarnya[1] principles of hierarchy are reconfiguring in the modern times and becoming omnipresent, nuanced, and embedded into all modern spaces with modern faces

  • Gopal Guru and Sundar Sarukai concede with observation above “In spite of various attempts to eradicate active caste consciousness in our society, it continues to erupt in most obnoxious ways consolidating caste identity

  • The active and effective presence of this caste consciousness has spread from the confines of the family to the political arena, from the private to the public spaces.”[3]. Citing the post Mandal[4] atmosphere in modern institution like universities and government institutions and private institutional workspaces, many studies have pointed out towards the reconfigured presence of caste in modern institution that often plays a vital role in systematic exclusion of the Dalits, Adivasi and, the minorities

Read more

Summary

MODERNITY AND CASTE

Caste inequalities in Indian society basing on Chaturvarnya[1] principles of hierarchy are reconfiguring in the modern times and becoming omnipresent, nuanced, and embedded into all modern spaces with modern faces. 3 Available at http://barefootphilosophers.wordpress.com/tag/gopal-guru/ 4 The Mandal Commission appointed in India in 1979 by the Janata Party government under Prime Minister Morarji Desai with a mandate to "identify the socially or educationally backward It was headed by Indian parliamentarian B.P. Mandal to consider the question of seat reservations and quotas for people to redress caste discrimination 5 Living a Concept: Semiotics of Everyday Exclusion By N Sukumaran EPW Vol - XLIII No 46, November 15, 2008. What is missing here is the fact that modern institutional space and structures itself are constituted for the benefit of dominant/ oppressive castes by themselves This atmosphere often alienates and discourages people from marginalized communities, so the language of understanding of these institutions itself acts as a matter of exclusion and humiliation. This situation is prevailing in both public and private sectors; state operated institutions, private institutions, and Development sector, the International and National Non-Government Organizations (INGOs and NGOs), which claim to working for the marginalized people and their empowerment

INDIAN CASTE BECOMING WORLD PROBLEM
THE INTERNATIONAL AID AGENCIES AND THEIR PERCEPTION OF CASTE
CASTE DIVERSITY IN DEVELOPMENT SECTOR
CHALLANGE CASTE IN CONSCIOUS LEVEL TO SYMBOLIC BOUNDARIES
Findings
COMMODIFICATING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATING DEMOCRATIC RIGHTS
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call