Assessment of advanced RANS turbulence models for the stability analysis of low specific speed pump-turbines

Abstract

Reversible pump-turbines, which can switch between pump and turbine operation, provide important support for the stabilization of the electrical grid. In order to fulfill their task, fast transition between the operation modes is required. This includes stable synchronization with the electrical grid during the process of turbine start at small guide vane openings (GVOs). However, the special geometry of pump-turbine impellers tends to produce unstable flow behavior, which can affect the synchronization process in a negative way.The prediction of the stability behavior with the help of CFD during the design process is not yet fully developed. The simulation of small specific speed pump-turbines operating at small GVOs sets high requirements on the underlying numerical model. To capture all relevant flow structures accordingly, 3-dimensional unsteady computation of the entire pump-turbine domain is required. Further, it has been shown that turbulence modeling is a key factor in order to reproduce the 4-quadrant characteristic in the unstable S-shape region. Vortex structures in the vaneless space and runner channels are considered the root-cause for the occurring instabilities. Standard two-equation models are not able to predict the stability behavior under these difficult circumstances (highly separated flows, small specific speed, small GVO angle). Models, which consider the anisotropic behavior of Reynolds-stresses have shown to produce better results.Considering the accurate prediction of mixing processes at off-design conditions, the focus was oriented to the anisotropy present in the turbulent structures. Standard models are often not sufficient to accurately predict vortices, which can have a huge impact on the performance, since based on the assumption of isotropic turbulence. Accordingly, they tend to dissipate and diffuse vortices too quickly. Improved models, which take the anisotropic nature of the Reynolds-stresses into account, can help in this context. The models can introduce the anisotropy via an explicit algebraic expression, or model directly the transport equations for the Reynolds-stresses. For this work the performance of a full Reynolds-stress model with improved coupling was investigated.In order to obtain the predictions using advanced turbulence models a particularly robust framework based on a pressure-based fully coupled approach was used. The goal of this work is the development and testing of an improved full Reynolds-stress model for the application in the stability analysis of pump-turbines. The focus lies thereby on separation behavior and mixing/vortex dissipation.