Modeling Separation-Induced Transition Using a Non-Linear Three Equation Turbulence Model and a Reynolds Stress Turbulence Model

Abstract

This paper presents an effort to model separation-induced transition on a flat plate with a semi-circular leading edge, by using two advanced turbulence models, the three equation non-linear model k-ε-A2 of Craft et al. [16] and the Reynolds-stress model of Craft [13]. The mechanism of the transition is governed by the different inlet velocity and turbulence intensity conditions, which lead to different recirculation bubbles and different transition onset points for each case. The use of advanced turbulence models in predicting the development of transitional flows has shown, in past studies, good perspectives. The k-ε-A2 model uses an additional transport equation for the A2 Reynolds stress invariant and it is an improvement of Craft et al. [12] non-linear eddy viscosity model. The use of the third transport equation gives improved results in the prediction of the longitudinal Reynolds stress distributions and especially, in flows where transitional phenomena may occur. Although this model is a pure eddy-viscosity model, it borrows many aspects from the more complex Reynolds-stress models. On the other hand, the use of an advanced Reynolds-stress turbulence model, such as the one of Craft [13], can predict many complex flows and there are indications that it can be applied to transitional flows also, since the crucial terms of Reynolds stress generation are computed exactly and normal stress anisotropy is resolved. The model of Craft [13], overcomes the drawbacks of the common used Reynolds-stress models regarding the computation of wall-normal distances and vectors in order to account for wall proximity effects. Instead of these quantities, it employs “normalized turbulence lengthscale gradients” which give the ability to identify the presence of strong inhomogeneity in a flow development, in an easier way. The final results of both turbulence models showed acceptable agreement with the experimental data. In this work it is shown that there is a good potential to model separation-induced transitional flows, with advanced turbulence modeling without any additional use of ad-hoc modifications or additional equations, based on various transition models.