The challenges facing urban youth in terms of both livelihoods and their involvement in local governance are increasingly recognized as some of the most important development issues worldwide. We also have remarkably few effective precedents on how to address these issues. And yet, for perhaps the first time ever in Environment and Urbanization, we have fewer themed papers in this issue than we do papers that provide feedback on themes in previous issues. We are disappointed and not a little chagrined at our failure to produce the bumper number on urban youth that was contemplated. The five papers we have certainly make an important contribution and we are delighted to be publishing them. However, some equally strong papers came in too late to be included (although these will feature in the April 2011 issue); also some research reports, while pointing in very interesting directions, were still too preliminary to be publishable; and in some cases, people who had been committed to contributing their rich experiences and strongly felt opinions turned out to be too busy to produce. We are looking forward to publishing in the next issue an overview by Richard Mabala on youth and livelihoods in Africa; an account of the youth federation in Nairobi that, in a sense, has grown up under the wing of the federation of the urban poor there but that has gone very much in its own direction; a discussion of deaf youth in large cities; an evaluation of a programme seeking to provide safe spaces and savings accounts for young girls in a Nairobi slum; and a description of the development of the Technical Training Resource Centre in Karachi, set up by a young engineering student and providing practical training for youth in construction, design and neighbourhood level mapping and documentation. There are some powerful narratives shaping the discourse around youth. On the one hand, they are seen as the problem – the unemployed, disaffected, irresponsible generation, a “ticking time bomb”, the ugly “bulge” that is likely to burst, spreading violence and chaos.(1) On the other hand, young people, and young women in particular, are seen as victims – victims of HIV, of violence, of sexual abuse, of discrimination, unemployment, exploitation. Yet another perspective is a vision of youth as the answer, a repository of knowledge, energy and vision that has only to be tapped to solve the world’s problems. This does not cover all the stereotypes around youth – in our next issue Richard Mabala will discuss a more complex typology. But these particular narratives, contradictory and simplistic as they are, can have a powerful influence on the ways in which young people are responded to, with often disappointing results. These papers offer a more thoughtful, nuanced middle ground, an area that clearly needs to be explored if the complex realities facing urban youth are to be more effectively addressed.
Read full abstract