Wi-Fi Coexistence Research Articles

WizBee: Wise ZigBee Coexistence via Interference Cancellation with Single Antenna

Coexistence of Wi-Fi and ZigBee in 2.4 GHz ISM band is a long standing and challenging problem. Previous solutions either require modifications of current ZigBee protocols or Wi-Fi re-configurations, which is not feasible in large-scale wireless sensor networks. In this paper, we present WizBee, a coexistence system using single-antenna sink without changing current Wi-Fi and ZigBee design. WizBee is based on an observation that Wi-Fi signal is about 5 to 20 dB stronger than ZigBee signal in symmetric area, which leaves much room for applying interference cancelation technique to mitigate Wi-Fi interference, and extract ZigBee signals. However, we need to cancel the Wi-Fi interference perfectly for residual ZigBee signal decoding, which needs more accurate channel coefficient across data transmissions in spite of cross technology interference. For robust and accurate Wi-Fi decoding, we use soft Viterbi decoding with weighted confidence value over interfered subcarriers. Consequently, our solution uses decoded data for channel coefficient estimation instead of conventional training symbol based methods. The key insight is that, the signal recovery opportunity for cross technology coexistence, lies in multi-domain information, such as power, frequency and coding discrepancies. Using these information properly will improve the coexistence network throughput effectively. We implemented WizBee in USRP/GNURadio software radio platform, and studied the decoding performance of interference cancelation technique. Our extensive evaluations under real wireless conditions show that WizBee improves ZigBee throughput up to $1.9\times$ , with median throughput gain of $1.2\times$ .

On the Impact of LTE-U on Wi-Fi Performance

With the exponential growth in mobile data traffic taking place currently and projected into the future, mobile operators need cost effective ways to manage the load of their networks. Traditionally, this has been achieved by offloading mobile traffic onto Wi-Fi networks due to their low cost and increasingly ubiquitous deployment. Recently, LTE operating in the unlicensed spectrum has drawn significant interests from mobile operators due to the availability of the unlicensed spectrum. Using this technology, the unlicensed spectrum is directly utilized by LTE without the need to offload traffic to an alternative radio access technology such as Wi-Fi. However, the deployment of LTE networks in the unlicensed band poses significant challenges to the performance of current and future Wi-Fi networks. We discuss the LTE and Wi-Fi coexistence challenges and present analysis on performance degradation of the Wi-Fi networks at the presence of LTE.

Dynamic Resource Adjustment for Coexistence of LAA and Wi-Fi in 5 GHz Unlicensed Bands

To enable the coexistence of Licensed Assisted Access (LAA) and Wi-Fi in 5 GHz unlicensed bands, a new channel access mechanism is proposed. Accounting for the fairness between LAA and Wi-Fi, the proposed mechanism finds the optimal transmission time ratio by adaptively adjusting the transmission durations for LAA and Wi-Fi. In addition, we propose a new analytical model for the distributed coordination function of IEEE 802.11 through some modifications of conventional analytical models for saturation and non-saturation loads. By computing the activity ratio of Wi-Fi, the proposed analytical model is able to control the time ratio between LAA and Wi-Fi, which is required for practical implementation of the proposed access mechanism. Through numerical simulations, the proposed channel access mechanism is compared with conventional methods in terms of throughput and utility.

Coexistence of Wi-Fi and heterogeneous small cell networks sharing unlicensed spectrum

As two major players in terrestrial wireless communications, Wi-Fi systems and cellular networks have different origins and have largely evolved separately. Motivated by the exponentially increasing wireless data demand, cellular networks are evolving towards a heterogeneous and small cell network architecture, wherein small cells are expected to provide very high capacity. However, due to the limited licensed spectrum for cellular networks, any effort to achieve capacity growth through network densification will face the challenge of severe inter-cell interference. In view of this, recent standardization developments have started to consider the opportunities for cellular networks to use the unlicensed spectrum bands, including the 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz bands that are currently used by Wi-Fi, Zigbee and some other communication systems. In this article, we look into the coexistence of Wi-Fi and 4G cellular networks sharing the unlicensed spectrum. We introduce a network architecture where small cells use the same unlicensed spectrum that Wi-Fi systems operate in without affecting the performance of Wi-Fi systems. We present an almost blank subframe (ABS) scheme without priority to mitigate the co-channel interference from small cells to Wi-Fi systems, and propose an interference avoidance scheme based on small cells estimating the density of nearby Wi-Fi access points to facilitate their coexistence while sharing the same unlicensed spectrum. Simulation results show that the proposed network architecture and interference avoidance schemes can significantly increase the capacity of 4G heterogeneous cellular networks while maintaining the service quality of Wi-Fi systems.

Coexistence of ZigBee-Based WBAN and WiFi for Health Telemonitoring Systems.

The development of telemonitoring via wireless body area networks (WBANs) is an evolving direction in personalized medicine and home-based mobile health. A WBAN consists of small, intelligent medical sensors which collect physiological parameters such as electrocardiogram, electroencephalography, and blood pressure. The recorded physiological signals are sent to a coordinator via wireless technologies, and are then transmitted to a healthcare monitoring center. One of the most widely used wireless technologies in WBANs is ZigBee because it is targeted at applications that require a low data rate and long battery life. However, ZigBee-based WBANs face severe interference problems in the presence of WiFi networks. This problem is caused by the fact that most ZigBee channels overlap with WiFi channels, severely affecting the ability of healthcare monitoring systems to guarantee reliable delivery of physiological signals. To solve this problem, we have developed an algorithm that controls the load in WiFi networks to guarantee the delay requirement for physiological signals, especially for emergency messages, in environments with coexistence of ZigBee-based WBAN and WiFi. Since WiFi applications generate traffic with different delay requirements, we focus only on WiFi traffic that does not have stringent timing requirements. In this paper, therefore, we propose an adaptive load control algorithm for ZigBee-based WBAN/WiFi coexistence environments, with the aim of guaranteeing that the delay experienced by ZigBee sensors does not exceed a maximally tolerable period of time. Simulation results show that our proposed algorithm guarantees the delay performance of ZigBee-based WBANs by mitigating the effects of WiFi interference in various scenarios.

Performance Evaluation of IEEE 802.15.4 Protocol Under Coexistence of WiFi 802.11b

Abstract ZigBee (IEEE 802.15.4) is a wireless mesh networking protocol low in cost, power, data rate, and complexity. To access Lo- cal Area Networks (LAN), 802.11b/g standard is used all over the world as Wi-Fi (Wireless Fidelity) standard. IEEE 802.15.4 Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) and IEEE 802.11b/g Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) are often collocated, causing a coexistence. The coexistence occurs because these networks share the same 2.4 GHz Industrial, Scientific, and Medical (ISM) band. A Simulation model has been introduced which completely reflects the ZigBee and WiFi coexistence. We have proposed frequency agility based interference avoidance algorithm . However, algorithm detects interference and adaptively switch nodes to safe channel for dynamically avoid WLAN interference with lower latency and energy consumption. The performance of ZigBee under WiFi is empirically evaluated in terms of the packet error rate (PER) and bit error rate (BER). The Simulation results us- ing frequency agility algorithm demonstrate that the design guideline can efficiently mitigate the effect of WiFi interference and enhance the performance of ZigBee networks.

Enabling the coexistence of LTE and Wi-Fi in unlicensed bands

The expansion of wireless broadband access network deployments is resulting in increased scarcity of available radio spectrum. It is very likely that in the near future, cellular technologies and wireless local area networks will need to coexist in the same unlicensed bands. However, the two most prominent technologies, LTE and Wi-Fi, were designed to work in different bands and not to coexist in a shared band. In this article, we discuss the issues that arise from the concurrent operation of LTE and Wi-Fi in the same unlicensed bands from the point of view of radio resource management. We show that Wi-Fi is severely impacted by LTE transmissions; hence, the coexistence of LTE and Wi-Fi needs to be carefully investigated. We discuss some possible coexistence mechanisms and future research directions that may lead to successful joint deployment of LTE and Wi-Fi in the same unlicensed band.

Content distribution in VANETs

Advances in vehicular communications technology are making content distribution to vehicles more effective and increasingly more popular. This paper presents state of the art technologies and protocols for content distribution in VANETs. Major challenges are Internet access spectrum scarcity, mobility, connectivity intermittence and scalability. Aspects covered in this paper include: coexistence of WiFi and LTE; application of network coding; protection from pollution attacks; incentive design for cooperation enforcement; QoS support for video streaming applications. Simulation and testbed results are presented to support the findings. Critical issues that will determine future directions in this area are identified and discussed.

NBP: light-weight Narrow Band Protection for ZigBee and Wi-Fi coexistence

Abstract The recent development of various wireless technologies in the 2.4GHz ISM band has led to the co-channel coexistence of heterogeneous wireless devices, such as Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and ZigBee. This sharing of the common channel results in the challenging problem of cross-technology interference, since the wireless devices generally use diverse PHY/MAC specifications. In particular, the less capable ZigBee device may often experience unpredictably low throughput due to the interference from the powerful Wi-Fi. The ZigBee protector is an attractive solution, since it can reserve the channel on behalf of the weak ZigBee devices. The protector method, however, has a few limitations; (i) it may cause significant overhead to both ZigBee and Wi-Fi, and (ii) the ZigBee control packets are still vulnerable to the Wi-Fi interference. In this paper, we propose a novel time reservation scheme called Narrow Band Protection (NBP), that uses a protector to guard the ongoing ZigBee transmission. The key contributions are threefold: First, NBP autonomously detects any ongoing ZigBee transmissions by cross-correlating the ZigBee’s packets with the pre-defined Pseudo-random Noise (PN) sequences. By using this cross-correlation, it significantly reduces the control overhead. Second, due to the reliable cross-correlation, NBP is robust from the control packet collisions, which typically wastes channel time for both ZigBee and Wi-Fi. Third, NBP protects the burst of ZigBee packets by estimating the size of the burst, in turn, giving a semantic to the PN codebook. This is important because ZigBee is typically battery-powered and thus the long burst is advantageous for the low duty cycle operations. We first show the feasibility of NBP by implementing it on the real USRP/GNURadio platform. Then, we evaluate the performance of NBP through mathematical analysis and NS-2 simulations. The results show that NBP enhances the ZigBee throughput by up to 1.77x compared to the existing scheme.

Coexistence of WiFi and WiMAX Systems Based on PS-Request Protocols

We introduce both the coexistence zone within the WiMAX frame structure and a PS-Request protocol for the coexistence of WiFi and WiMAX systems sharing a frequency band. Because we know that the PS-Request protocol has drawbacks, we propose a revised PS-Request protocol to improve the performance. Two PS-Request protocols are based on the time division operation (TDO) of WiFi system and WiMAX system to avoid the mutual interference, and use the vestigial power management (PwrMgt) bit within the Frame Control field of the frames transmitted by a WiFi AP. The performance of the revised PS-Request protocol is evaluated by computer simulation, and compared to those of the cases without a coexistence protocol and to the original PS-Request protocol.

Developing ZigBee Deployment Guideline Under WiFi Interference for Smart Grid Applications

Smart grid is an intelligent power generation, distribution, and control system. ZigBee, as a wireless mesh networking scheme low in cost, power, data rate, and complexity, is ideal for smart grid applications, e.g., real-time system monitoring, load control, and building automation. Unfortunately, almost all ZigBee channels overlap with wireless local area network (WLAN) channels, resulting in severe performance degradation due to interference. In this paper, we aim to develop practical ZigBee deployment guideline under the interference of WLAN. We identify the “Safe Distance” and “Safe Offset Frequency” using a comprehensive approach including theoretical analysis, software simulation, and empirical measurement. In addition, we propose a frequency agility-based interference avoidance algorithm. The proposed algorithm can detect interference and adaptively switch nodes to “safe” channel to dynamically avoid WLAN interference with small latency and small energy consumption. Our proposed scheme is implemented with a Meshnetics ZigBit Development Kit and its performance is empirically evaluated in terms of the packet error rate (PER) using a ZigBee and Wi-Fi coexistence test bed. It is shown that the empirical results agree with our analytical results. The measurements demonstrate that our design guideline can efficiently mitigate the effect of WiFi interference and enhance the performance of ZigBee networks.

Coexistence of WiFi and WiMAX Systems Based on Coexistence Zone within WiMAX Frame Structure and Modified Power Saving Mode of WiFi System

Various co-sited wireless communication systems may share the same frequency band. This causes mutual interference between the wireless communication systems, and degrades the performance of each wireless communication system. In this paper, we analyze the effect of mutual interference between WiFi and WiMAX systems sharing the same frequency band. We propose novel methods based on a proposed coexistence zone within the WiMAX frame structure and a modified power saving mode of the WiFi system to solve the problem. We evaluate the performance of the proposed methods by computer simulation.