Possession of a negative self-concept is often seen as a factor in the poor academic achievement of Indian youth (for a summary, see U.S. Senate, 1969). Recent evidence suggests that Indians and other non-white youth do not necessarily see themselves as inferior persons in the school setting, however. The National Study of American Indian Education (Fuchs and Havighurst, 1973), for example, reported that a nation-wide sample of Indian youth viewed themselves as fairly competent persons in their own social world and also when compared to non-Indian youth of similar socioeconomic status. Likewise, an increasing number of studies indicate that black pupils may have a level of self-esteem not significantly different from, or even higher than that of white pupils (cf. Rosenberg and Simmons, 1972; Zirkel and Moses, 1971). In spite of their generally positive stance, Fuchs and Havighurst emphasize, however, that the social world in which the Indian youth feels competent is one of Indianness and poverty. Contact with the expectations of teachers and others in an urban-industrial and/or middle-class environment would likely lead to some self-doubt. Nonetheless, they argue that Indian youth do not generally feel depressed, inferior, and powerless. Fuchs and Havighurst, in fact, have taken strong issue with much of the traditional literature on Indian education and self-esteem because the majority of these studies rely upon observations by non-Indians or upon data secured from personality tests which, for a variety of reasons-urban and/or white middle-class bias, non-representative forced choice responses, required level of reading ability and English language skills, and the like-may be inappropriate for measuring Indian perceptions of Indian life (see also Dreyer, 1970a, 1970b; Dreyer and Havighurst, 1970; Havighurst, 1970). Fuchs and Havighurst are especially critical of the influential Bryde (1970) study of Sioux adolescents using the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory which appeared to show that Sioux youth suffered from severe personality and emotional problems. The MMPI, they point out, is designed for diagnosing psychotic adults and is difficult for poor readers. Their review of Bryde's data also suggested that a large percentage of the scores were technically invalid (see Dreyer and Havighurst, 1970). It appears, therefore, that a serious reevaluation of the literature concerning the levels of self-esteem which Indian youth as*This study was funded as part of a larger study by the Governor's Planning -Committee on Criminal Administration, Cheyenne, Wyoming (Grant N. 72A-22-189). The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the position, policy or endorsement of the Governor's Planning Committee. The authors would like to acknowledge the assistance of Rolland Raboin and Betty Wells in gathering of data, and the comments of Norman Denzin, Morris Forslund, James Hood, and Michael Massarotti on an earlier draft of this paper.
Read full abstract