An evaluation of Charpy impact toughness of the weld metal for laser beam welds is often impossible due to occurrence of fracture path deviation (FPD) from the weld metal into base steel. Therefore, the improved toughness evaluation method using side-grooved specimen instead of normal specimen has been suggested for preventing FPD. However, for a pre-qualification of the toughness of laser welds, the toughness value obtained with side-grooved specimen should be corrected to the toughness value of normal Charpy specimen. In this study, the method for correction of side-grooved Charpy energy for laser welds to normal Charpy impact toughness suggested by Hagihara et al. (Q J Jpn Weld Soc 25: 165–172, 2007) is advanced by means of FE analysis with focus on the deformation behaviors associated with strength mismatch. Furthermore, the distinctive strength mismatch of laser welds on lateral contraction of Charpy specimen has been analyzed by means of the Weibull stress approach. The applicability of the advanced engineering method is demonstrated by comparing experimental result, whereas the further verification should be accumulated.